Background Germline mutations in the phosphatase PTEN are associated with diverse human pathologies, including tumour susceptibility, developmental abnormalities and autism, but any genotype-phenotype relationships are poorly understood.
Methods We have studied the functional consequences of seven PTEN mutations identified in patients diagnosed with autism and macrocephaly and five mutations from severe tumour bearing sufferers of PTEN hamartoma tumour syndrome (PHTS).
Results All seven autism-associated PTEN mutants investigated retained the ability to suppress cellular AKT signalling, although five were highly unstable. Observed effects on AKT also correlated with the ability to suppress soma size and the length and density of dendritic spines in primary neurons. Conversely, all five PTEN mutations from severe cases of PHTS appeared to directly and strongly disrupt the ability to inhibit AKT signalling.
Conclusions Our work implies that alleles causing incomplete loss of PTEN function are more commonly linked to autism than to severe PHTS cases.
- Cancer: breast
- Cell biology
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt and build upon this work, for commercial use, provided the original work is properly cited. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Phosphatase and tensin homologue deleted on chromosome ten (PTEN) is a phosphatase that suppresses the activity of the class I phosphoinositide 3-kinase/AKT signalling pathway.1 It has been heavily studied due to its status as a tumour suppressor gene in which loss of function mutations are identified in many sporadic tumours and in the germline of patients with diverse phenotypes. Inherited dominant PTEN mutations have been identified in patients with Cowden syndrome and Bannayan-Riley-Ruvalcaba syndrome, conditions that are often grouped together as PTEN hamartoma tumour syndrome (PHTS). They have also been identified in a fraction of patients with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) who also display macrocephaly with and without additional developmental phenotypes characteristic of PHTS.2–8 Supporting the causality of PTEN mutations in these phenotypes, a similar tumour spectrum and autism-like phenotypes have been identified in mice either carrying a single null Pten allele or with tissue-specific deletion of Pten.9–11
The major diagnostic criteria for PHTS include malignancies of the breast, thyroid and endometrium in addition to benign hamartomas, skin lesions and macrocephaly.12 However, the symptoms associated with PTEN mutations are diverse and in some cases, germline mutations have been identified in adult patients only upon presentation with malignancy13 ,14 and in patients with macrocephaly, autism and/or learning disability without further symptoms.5 ,15 A series of clinical and laboratory based studies have presented evidence that mutational functional diversity and genetic background may each contribute to the phenotypical diversity observed in patients carrying PTEN mutations. In some families, individuals carrying the same PTEN mutation have been noted to display very different phenotypes, to the extent of separate diagnoses of Cowden syndrome and Bannayan-Riley-Ruvalcaba syndrome.16 ,17 Additionally, the spectrum of tumours arising in heterozygous mice carrying a null allele of Pten also appears to be strongly dependent on genetic background.18 Studies of the mutation types (missense vs truncation) and positions (phosphatase vs C2 domain) within PTEN have argued for19 and against2 ,20 genotype-phenotype relationships. On the other hand, evidence that not all PTEN mutations cause one phenotypical profile has been provided by studies of heterozygous mice expressing a stable Pten mutant protein either lacking all phosphatase activity, Pten C124S or that selectively lacks lipid phosphatase activity, Pten G129E. These mice display a more severe tumour phenotype than mice carrying a Pten deletion allele21 ,22 indicating that inactive Pten can aggravate phenotypes, particularly tumour severity, through dominant negative mechanisms. However, whether this represents a consistent genotype-phenotype relationship within PTEN mutation carriers, in particular relating to the occurrence of ASD, is unclear.
PTEN missense mutations identified in patients with autism are catalytically competent
Recombinant PTEN protein purified from bacteria has been used in many previous studies to demonstrate that phosphatase activity is critical for its tumour suppressor function. In preliminary experiments studying three PTEN mutants identified in patients with autism, we could detect little or no catalytic activity in vitro from protein purified from bacteria, yet transient expression of these mutants in mammalian cells led to a robust suppression of the phosphorylation of the PTEN regulated kinase AKT (see online supplementary figure S1A, B). This apparent difference between assay formats encouraged us to analyse a larger group of seven mutant proteins identified in patients with autism (figure 1A) lacking other manifestations of PHTS.3–7 Therefore, we used lentiviruses to express either PTEN wild-type (WT) or individual missense PTEN mutants (C124S, G129R, H118P, H123Q, E157G, F241S, D252G, N276S and D326N) in PTEN-null U87MG glioblastoma cells. These include two recognised active site PTEN mutants that lack catalytic activity: PTEN C124S and PTEN G129R. We expressed PTEN WT and each mutant using five increasing doses of each viral vector (figure 1C). Investigating effects on cellular AKT phosphorylation, when expressed at similar levels, all seven of the autism-related mutants showed similar (or in some cases possibly greater) effects to PTEN WT on AKT phosphorylation, whereas a lack of activity was observed with the inactive mutants PTEN C124S and G129R (figure 1C, D and see online supplementary figure S3A). These data show that the mutations identified in patients with autism do not greatly reduce the ability of the expressed PTEN proteins to inhibit cellular AKT signalling and imply that these mutants retain catalytic activity.
To test their phosphatase activity directly, we overexpressed each protein in U87MG cells and assayed freshly immunopurified PTEN proteins in vitro against radiolabelled phosphatidylinositol 3,4,5-trisphosphate (PIP3) vesicles. Recovered activities were weak for many of the PTEN mutants, but this correlated with a low recovery of immunoprecipitated PTEN, probably due to poor stability of these mutants during the immunopurification process (see online supplementary figure S2). In particular, PTEN H118P, F241S, D252G and N276S were recovered poorly and gave very weak activity. Activity normalised to reflect PTEN protein content showed robust activity for all mutants, although weaker than wild type enzyme (see online supplementary figure S2). These experiments also indicate that testing the protein phosphatase activity would be problematic. In addition to this difficulty immunoprecipitating active protein, during these experiments, it was noted that to express most of the autism-related PTEN missense mutations at the same level as PTEN WT protein, a higher titre of lentivirus was consistently required (see online supplementary figures S2A and S3A). Therefore, we investigated the possibility that these mutations affected the stability of the PTEN protein.
Reduced protein stability of autism-associated PTEN mutants
To investigate the relationship between the cellular abundance of PTEN mRNA and protein for the mutants, we expressed PTEN WT and mutants in U87MG cells and measured PTEN mRNA levels by real-time qPCR and protein by western blotting. In all cases, the mRNA abundance corresponded to the titre of lentivirus applied in the experiment. The expression of PTEN WT and the widely used stable mutants, C124S and G129R was robust and similar, as was the expression of two of the autism-associated mutants, H123Q and E157G. However, we observed that for five of the autism-associated mutants (H118P, F241S, D252G, N276S and D326N) the amount of protein expressed was very low (figure 1D, E).
To assess more directly the stability of these mutant proteins relative to PTEN WT, we used the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide (200 µg/mL). Transduced cells were incubated with the inhibitor for 0 h, 2 h, 4 h, 6 h and 8 h, followed by immunodetection using anti-PTEN antibody (figure 2A, B). Whereas the protein level of PTEN WT and some mutants (C124S, G129R, H123Q and E157G) was reduced by ∼20% after 8 h of inhibition of protein synthesis, the protein level for the PTEN mutants H118P, F241S, D252G, N276S and D326N was decreased by ∼60% after 8 h (figure 2A, B), and was significantly lower than PTEN WT, supporting the hypothesis that these five mutants are unstable.
Molecular characterisation in primary neurons of the PTEN mutations identified in patients with autism
Macrocephaly is one of the several anatomical and cellular abnormalities that have been suggested to be important factors in the pathogenesis of ASD.23 Work carried out in mice showed that PTEN can control neuronal morphology and growth, with hypertrophy and dendritic overgrowth and development of macrocephaly and additional behavioural phenotypes similar to human autism observed in mice lacking PTEN in neurons.10 ,24–27 We have therefore used neurons from which endogenous Pten is deleted to investigate whether the physiological level re-expression of PTEN WT or autism-associated PTEN mutants is able to support a wild type phenotype of normal dendritic growth and neuronal size. Hippocampal neurons prepared from E15.5 flox/flox Pten mice were transduced simultaneously with lentiviruses expressing Cre recombinase (RFP-Cre) to delete endogenous Pten and with viruses encoding PTEN WT or PTEN mutants. The mutants PTEN H123Q, F241S and D326N were selected to represent a range of protein stabilities (see figure 2). The deletion of the endogenous Pten genes and the re-expression of human PTEN mutants were verified by western blot (figure 3D). Deletion of Pten led to an increase in Akt phosphorylation which was not reduced by the expression of PTEN C124S. The mutant F241S expressed very poorly, however the mutants H123Q and D326N were expressed and able to downregulate Akt phosphorylation as was PTEN WT. These results confirmed that when expressed at physiological levels these mutants are biologically active. We wanted then to verify the effect that they have on soma size and the morphology of dendritic spines by immunocytochemistry. In order to analyse neuronal morphology, 6 days after transduction and 24 h before being fixed and stained, neuronal cultures were lipofected with vectors encoding yellow fluorescent protein to allow the morphological analysis of a transfected neuronal subpopulation (including identifiable transduced and untransduced cells). PTEN WT significantly reduced the soma size (figure 3B, C) of hippocampal neurons, as well as the density and length of dendritic spines (figure 3E–G) to levels similar to control neurons (from which endogenous Pten had not been deleted), relative to neurons expressing Cre, with or without additional inactive PTEN C124S. In agreement with the previous results, we found that the autism-related mutants H123Q and D326N were capable of controlling these morphological changes in broad correlation with the amount of protein expressed, showing effect similar to PTEN WT when expressing similar amount of protein. PTEN F241S expressed very poorly and did not affect neuronal signalling or morphology in accordance with its very low apparent stability.
PTEN mutations identified in severe cases of PHTS lack activity
Considering the view that patients diagnosed only with ASD and macrocephaly may reflect a group at the milder end of the spectrum of phenotypes associated with PTEN mutations, we chose to select a comparator group of mutations associated with a severe tumour bearing PHTS phenotype. To do this, we conducted an extensive search of data published in journals and online resources associating specific PTEN mutations with phenotype (see online supplementary tables S1–S3). Although inconsistencies in the categorisation of patients’ severity are likely to be introduced by diversity in the diagnosis and recording of separate phenotypical characteristics between publications, our analysis identified 112 missense mutations that had sufficient associated phenotypical data and which had been identified in a total of 204 patients (see online supplementary tables S2, S3). This analysis shows that missense mutations (rather than truncating mutations) were overrepresented among all PTEN mutation carriers described with ASD compared with all carriers of PTEN mutations, consistent with the hypothesis that more of these mutants may retain some activity (figure S3).
Five PTEN missense mutations associated with the most severe phenotype (score >6) were selected for characterisation (PTEN A39P, N48K, L108P, L112P and R130L (figure 4A)). These were expressed in U87MG cells together with the already described stable and inactive PTEN mutants C124S, G129R and G129E. The latter two have been identified in Cowden syndrome sufferers and in our classification were associated with a mild/moderate phenotype. When transduced into U87MG cells using lentiviruses, two of these mutant cDNAs (A39P and N48K) were expressed with similar efficiency to WT PTEN but did not suppress cellular AKT phosphorylation (figure 4C). The other three mutants (L108P, L112P and R130L) expressed less efficiency compared with PTEN WT, but when expression was forced to this level, they also failed to downregulate AKT phosphorylation (figure 4C and see online supplementary figure S3B). Analysis of the half-life of PTEN mutant proteins showed that two of the mutations (L108P and L112P) destabilise the protein with a decrease in protein levels by ∼60–80% after 8 h of protein synthesis inhibition, whereas the protein level for the mutants A39P, N48K and R130L, as well as for PTEN WT, C124S, G129E and G129R was reduced by ∼20% (figure 4D, E). This finding that when expressed at the same level as wild type PTEN, all the seven PTEN mutations associated with ASD, but none of the five associated with severe Cowden syndrome analysed was able to regulate AKT is significant (two-tailed Fisher’s exact test p=0.0013).
Our data show that all seven PTEN mutant proteins that we investigated due to their identification in patients with ASD retained the capacity to suppress cellular phosphoinositide 3-kinase-AKT signalling when they were expressed to the same level as wild type PTEN. However, most of these mutant PTEN proteins are unstable and it would be expected that in vivo this instability would lead to a very considerable reduction in protein abundance relative to PTEN WT and a resultant reduction in biological activity. Functional evaluation of PTEN mutants in a yeast based system has previously found significantly lower activity in a set of PHTS/Cowden-associated PTEN mutations than in autism-associated mutations,28 although it was unclear whether this effect related to direct inactivating mutations or poor protein stability. It has already been reported for another mutant associated with ASD, PTEN H93R, that this mutation caused a significant reduction in activity in vitro and in cells, to approximately 15% of wild type activity in vitro.29 In agreement with our own data, it seems possible that strong but incomplete loss of activity may be related to the observation of ASD symptoms in the absence of some of the more severe phenotypes seen in some patients with Cowden syndrome. In this regard, we have observed mutations that would lead to loss of function through instability and through direct incomplete loss of activity.
In contrast, when a set of PTEN mutations associated with the most severe cases of Cowden syndrome were tested for their cellular activity, all of these five mutant proteins were found to display no detectable effect on AKT phosphorylation even when overexpressed. This implies that complete loss of activity may associate with a more severe PHTS/Cowden phenotype. Of these five proteins, three showed stability similar to wild type PTEN, whereas two were unstable. In the cases of the stable mutants, this supports a hypothesis that the expression of stable inactive protein may exacerbate the phenotype caused by PTEN loss of function, through interference with the functions of the remaining WT PTEN protein and possibly other proteins. Strong evidence supporting the potential importance of this effect comes from the observed phenotypes of Pten knockin mice, in which the most severe tumour phenotype was observed in mice expressing stable PTEN mutants lacking lipid phosphatase activity, G129E or C124S, relative to either mice carrying a Pten deletion or with an unstable PTEN mutation.21 ,22 However, other mechanisms may be involved as this would not seem to explain the occurrence of unstable catalytically inactive PTEN mutants (L108P and L112P) in severe PHTS. Therefore, although the mechanisms mediating these effects are unclear, our work characterises a novel correlation between specific human patient groups and the features of the PTEN mutations they carry.
Our work implies that mutation-specific factors do contribute to the severity of PTEN mutation carriers’ symptoms. These effects may relate to the retention of some biological PTEN activity in the case of patients displaying macrocephaly and ASD in the absence of more severe developmental phenotypes, and to the expression of dominant negative inactive PTEN protein in some cases combining severe developmental and eventually tumour phenotypes. Biochemically, potential dominant negative effects of mutant PTEN proteins have not been extensively studied, although data supporting the functional importance of PTEN dimerisation has very recently been published.21 The first trials are underway of potential targeted therapies, such as inhibitors of the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) kinase activated downstream of PTEN loss, to treat patients with inherited PTEN mutations and severe phenotypes. Through a deeper understanding of the signalling mechanisms driving specific phenotypes, it may eventually be possible to tailor treatments to individual patient groups based upon their early symptoms and on an understanding of the cellular effects of defined classes of mutation.
Materials and methods
U87MG glioblastoma cells culture, lentivirus preparation and titration were as previously described.30 U87MG cells were transduced with lentivirus particles in a medium supplemented with polybrene (16 µg/mL; hexadimethrine bromide, Sigma). Media were changed 24 h after transduction, and after a further 24 h cells were processed. To delete the Pten gene from cultured Pten flox-flox murine neurons, a modified lentiviral vector was used in which the expression of the RFP-Cre transgene is driven by a human synapsin-1 promoter.31 ,32 RFP-Cre lentiviruses were produced by triple cotransfection of 6.5 million HEK293 T cells in 75 cm flasks with 10 µg lentiviral vector, 7.5 µg pHR-CMV 8.9 deltaR packaging vector and 5 µg pCMV VSV-G envelop vector using X-tremeGENE 9 DNA transfection reagent (Roche). The 10 mL of viral supernatant was harvested 48 h after transfection, filtered using 0.22 µ filter (Millipore) and the aliquots were snap frozen in liquid nitrogen for 10 min before storing them at −80°C.
Primary neuron cultures
Hippocampi were isolated from embryonic day 15.5 Pten flox-flox mice (E15.5) and digested in trypsin to obtain dissociated cells as described in Kreis et al.33 Primary hippocampal cells were resuspended in neurobasal medium supplemented with B-27 (serum-free supplement) and cultured on poly-L-ornithine (15 µg/mL, Sigma) coated coverslips at 37°C in 5% CO2 for immunocytochemistry and biochemical analysis.
RFP-Cre lentivirus particles were added to the neuronal culture 7 days after seeding, together with lentivirus particles encoding WT or mutant forms of PTEN and left for 6 days. Every 2–3 days half of the medium was replaced by fresh medium. Neuronal cells used for immunocytochemistry were transfected with yellow fluorescent protein 24 h before fixation by using Lipofectamine 2000 as transfection reagent (0.6 µg DNA/0.8 µL Lipofectamine in Optimem). Of the medium 250 µL was removed, collected in a tube, mixed with fresh media in a 1:1 ratio and incubated at 37°C. Transfection mix was added to the cells for 20 min and then removed and replaced by the incubated media. Cells used for biochemical analysis were washed in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) and lysed using RIPA buffer (RIPA lysis and extraction buffer, Thermo Scientific, 25 mM Tris-HCL pH 7.6, 150 mM NaCl, 1% NP-40, 1% sodium deoxycholate, 0.1% sodium dodecylsulphate (SDS), protease inhibitors and phosphatase inhibitors).
The authors thank the members of the NRL and BJE laboratories for their technical support and constructive discussions.
This web only file has been produced by the BMJ Publishing Group from an electronic file supplied by the author(s) and has not been edited for content.
Files in this Data Supplement:
- Data supplement 1 - Online supplement
Contributors LS, BJE and NRL conceived the study plan. LS performed the experiments. LS, FMB, JNB, BJE and NRL analysed the data. LS and NRL wrote the manuscript. All authors contributed to revision and approved the final manuscript.
Funding This work was funded by the Medical Research Council (grant code G0801865), a short-term fellowship to LS from the Federation of European Biochemical Societies (FEBS) and in the University of Dundee by the pharmaceutical companies of the DSTT consortium (Astra Zeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, GlaxoSmithKline, Merck KGaA and Pfizer).
Competing interests None.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.