Girls and women with Turner syndrome are at risk for catastrophic aortic dissection and rupture, but the clinical profile for those at risk is not well described. In addition to reporting two new cases, we performed an electronic search to identify all reported cases of aortic dissection associated with Turner syndrome. Particular attention was paid to the reporting of systemic hypertension (HTN) and congenital heart disease (CHD) which are known risk factors for aortic disease in the general population. In total, 85 cases of aortic dissection in TS were reported between 1961 and 2006. Dissection occurred at a young age, 30.7 (range 4–64) years, which is significantly earlier than its occurrence in the general female population (68 years). Of the cases for which HTN and CHD were explicitly assessed, 15% had HTN alone, 30% had CHD alone and 34% had both. Importantly, in 11% of the cases, neither HTN nor CHD were identified, suggesting that TS alone is an independent risk factor for aortic dissection; however, the cases where no risk factors were identified were very poorly documented. Dissection in women with TS undergoing assisted reproductive techniques (ART) frequently resulted in death. The literature on aortic dissection in TS is sparse and most cases are poorly documented, making it difficult to establish firm guidelines regarding monitoring and treatment. A TS aortic dissection registry has been established to better determine the natural history and risk factors (http://www.tssus.org/readweb.asp?wid = 3092).
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Aortic dissection occurs in individuals with disorders of connective tissue, including those caused by fibrillin mutations (Marfan syndrome), collagen mutations (Ehlers–Danlos syndrome), transforming growth factor (TGF)-β receptor mutations (Loeys–Dietz syndrome), and in those in which a connective tissue disorder is postulated but not proven, such as bicuspid aortic valve syndrome and Turner syndrome (TS). In Marfan syndrome, guidelines for monitoring of aortic root dimension and indications for surgical intervention to prevent dissection are established, but for those with less common causes, treatment guidelines are lacking. In TS in particular, the medical community has been slow to recognise the evidence for the significant risk of catastrophic aortic dissection. This is partly because aortic dissection is relatively rare in TS (1.4%).1 Perhaps more importantly, the little information available is diffuse and disorganised, consisting of clinic-based studies,2 unverified data obtained from questionnaires,3 and sporadic cases reports that describe only one or two cases of aortic dissection. A comprehensive review describing all of the reported cases of aortic dissection in TS has not been published. We describe two previously unreported cases of dissection occurring in young women with TS, review all of the published cases of aortic dissection occurring in TS, and announce the establishment of the International Turner Syndrome Aortic Dissection Registry. In this review, particular attention was paid to cases in which only the diagnosis of TS was present and other predisposing risk factors, such as congenital heart disease (CHD) or systemic hypertension (HTN), were expressly absent.
An 18-year-old woman with TS (45,X) presented to an emergency department with full cardiac arrest. She had a 4-day history of chest pain. The patient died soon after presentation, and an autopsy revealed type A aortic dissection.
The patient had been treated with a tumour necrosis factor blocker (infliximab) for Crohn disease for 8 years. TS was diagnosed at the age of 14 years after an evaluation for short stature and delay of pubertal development. An echocardiogram performed at the time of the initial TS evaluation found a non-obstructive, functionally bicuspid aortic valve and trace aortic valve insufficiency. The patient had a mildly dilated ascending aorta of 28.5 mm (Z-score = 3.1). There was no evidence of coarctation. At 17 years of age, another echocardiogram reported ascending aorta diameters of 28 and 32 mm (Z-score = 2.2 to 3.8). Blood pressure was normal (102/60). Two days before death, the patient reported chest and upper back pain. Blood pressure was 108/84. The patient had abdominal pain with palpation and an audible abdominal bruit. Her paediatric cardiologist did not think there was a cardiac basis for her pain. She was told she had gastritis and started on antacid treatment.
A 29-year-old woman with TS (45, X) presented to the emergency department with a 2-day history of shortness of breath and intermittent chest pain. Shortly after presentation, she became unresponsive, apnoeic and pulseless. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation was started, but the patient died. Before the arrest, pallor and rales had been noted and thrombolytic treatment started for presumed pulmonary embolus. Type A aortic dissection was found at autopsy. In addition to TS, the patient had a bicuspid aortic valve, hypertension (treated with atenolol), hypothyroidism, and a history of bipolar disorder that was treated with lithium and an antidepressant.
The patient’s most recent echocardiogram 15 months prior to the dissection showed a mildly thickened aortic valve without stenosis or insufficiency, mild mitral valve thickening and normal systolic function. The aortic root diameter measured 22 mm (z = −0.5). Despite beta-blocker treatment, the most recent blood pressure measurements showed systemic hypertension (142/82).
We performed an electronic search from 1961 to 2006 designed to capture all reported cases of aortic dissection in girls and women with TS (key words: Turner syndrome, aortic dissection, aortic dilatation). Cases were excluded if aortic dissection in Turner syndrome was not explicit. However, cases were still included in the review even if the method of diagnosing heart disease or measuring blood pressure were not precisely stated. In total, 23 articles, 5 short commentaries, 4 letters to the editor and 8 abstracts were ultimately included in this report. Cases were cross-referenced in order to avoid duplication of cases. Age at dissection, location of dissection, mention of known risk factors (ie CHD and/or HTN), treatment and outcome were recorded.
In total, 88 cases were reported between 1961–2006. Of these, 85 cases were included in this review; 3 cases were excluded because they lacked identifying information. The mean age at time of dissection was 30.7 (range 4–64) years. Over half the patients were aged <30 years. A karyotype was reported in 58% (49/85). A 45X karyotype was present in 80% (39/49) of the cases where karyotype was reported. In 10 cases, various forms of mosaicism were described: 45X/46XX (1 patient), 45X/46XY (3), 45X/46X,r(X) (4), 45X/46X+mar4 (1) and not specified (1). The location of the aortic dissection was provided in 71 of the 85 cases. Over half (55%; 47/85) of the dissections occurred in the proximal aorta and 23% (20/85) in the distal aorta. In three cases, both the ascending and descending aortas were involved. CHD was reported in 69% (51/74) cases that were evaluated for CHD. Of these 51 cases, 47% (24/51) had reported coarctation of the aorta, 27% (14/51) bicuspid aortic valve (BAV) and 18% (9/51) both BAV and a coarctation. Of the 65 cases in which blood pressure and CHD were both explicitly assessed (fig 1), 54% (35/65) had hypertension, although in most of the cases the blood pressure values were not reported. In addition, in this group, for which both risk factors were assessed, 75% (49/65) had associated CHD. The online supplementary tables (available at http://jmg.bmj.com/supplemental) report the cases in which CHD occurred in isolation (Table S1, references 4–20), in which hypertension was the only risk factor described (Table S2, references 21–24), and in which both CHD and hypertension were present (Table S3, references 25–39).
Assisted reproductive technology (ART) resulted in pregnancy complicated by aortic dissection in six instances.40–44 In a seventh case death occurred 1 year after ART.40 Maternal death was reported in 86% (6/7) of these cases.
No risk factors were reported in 21% (18/85) overall (table 1). Importantly, most case reports that listed no risk factors did not explicitly exclude them. However, in 11% (7/65), the presence (or absence) of CHD and HTN was specifically investigated and not identified (table 1, fig 1). The age range of these seven women was between 20 and 53 (mean 36) years. In one case, aortic dissection occurred during the third trimester in a pregnant women who had ART.40 Four of six cases reported a proximal aortic dissection and in one case the dissection was both proximal and distal. Although all seven cases excluded HTN and CHD, only two cases reported the actual blood pressure values, and the method used to exclude CHD was described in only three cases.
The symptoms most commonly reported before dissection were chest pain, diaphoresis and tachycardia. In the majority of cases, surgical and/or medical treatments were tried. In all 22 instances in which the pathology of the aorta was reported, it was found to be cystic medial necrosis. In 83 of the cases an outcome was reported, with death occurring in 48/83 cases (58%).
In this review, 85 cases of dissection of the aorta were identified in women with TS. These data demonstrate that in most cases a known risk factor for dissection is present, either systemic hypertension, a predisposing cardiac malformation or both. Of significant concern are the reports of aortic dissection occurring in seven women during ART. In one study of pregnancy in women with coarctation, the only death was due to aortic dissection in a woman with TS.42 Although there are no data regarding how commonly ART is undertaken by TS women, the fact that most women (86%) in our review died suggests that pregnancy is a major risk factor in TS. Dissection of the aorta occurs in TS at a remarkably young age (mean 31 years). In contrast, the International Registry of Acute Aortic Dissection found that the mean age of dissection in non-TS women is 68 years.45 Furthermore, aortic dissection is predominantly a male disease (male:female ratio 3.2:1, age-adjusted mortality rate).46 The reasons that aortic dissection occurs in this unique group of young women deserves further attention.
Bicuspid aortic valve, aortic coarctation and systemic hypertension are established risk factors for aortic dissection in the general population47 and they often occur in TS. Approximately 25–30% of women with TS have a cardiovascular malformation and of those affected, most have aortic disease.48 49 Systemic hypertension has been reported to occur in 50% of women with TS.49 Thus, in TS there appears to be a confluence of established risk factors leading to aortic dissection. In support of this theory, we found that 89% of cases of aortic dissection had at least one established risk factor.
On the other hand, we and others3 have found no identifiable risk factor in approximately 11% of cases. This could be because the known associations were not adequately assessed. Indeed, the cases we reviewed that carried the claim of no risk factors were, for the most part, very poorly documented. However, others have suggested that TS involves a primary disorder of the composition of the aortic wall that creates vulnerability by lowering the threshold for dilation, dissection and rupture. The data in table 1 showing that some patients had neither of the established risk factors suggest that TS alone may be predisposing to aortic dissection. Histological evidence of cystic medial necrosis in aortic tissue taken from patients with bicuspid aortic valve, Marfan syndrome and TS suggests a common aetiology despite genetically diverse backgrounds. In this regard, Ostberg et al50 recently documented intimal–medial thickening and vessel dilation diffusely in the vasculature, including the aorta in women with TS, even in the absence of CHD. Interestingly, similar pathological findings are typically present in other aortopathies, including Marfan syndrome. The presence of vessel wall thickening in these diseases is evidence against the conventional view that increased wall stress produced by high blood pressure, jets from stenotic aortic valves, or abnormal proteins of the aortic tissue produce thinning of the vessel wall, which leads to dilation and eventual aortic rupture. Other observations51 suggest that a disorder of growth-factor signal transduction ultimately weakens the aortic wall. These studies report a variety of aortic diseases in which there is a constellation of findings, including vessel wall thickening, upregulation of TGF-β signalling and proliferation of matrix proteins. In TS the observation of aortic wall thickening suggests that it may also be a disorder associated with upregulation of TGF-β signalling.
Knowledge of the natural history and clinical findings of Marfan syndrome has been used to make judgments regarding proper monitoring and treatment of TS individuals with aortic enlargement. However, it is clear from this review that very little is known about the prodrome of aortic dissection in this population. For example, it is completely unknown whether aortic dissection is preceded by progressive dilation of the aortic root as it is in Marfan syndrome. Indeed, in both of the new cases presented in this report, the most recent aortic Z-score determined by echocardiography was <4, a value that most cardiologists would not consider to be at risk for imminent dissection. We conclude from our review that there is a profound lack of a reliable medical profile for those with TS who have dissected. Accordingly, it is appropriate that the position of the American Academy of Pediatrics on the monitoring and management of aortic disease in TS is open-ended, recommending that medical monitoring should be determined by the primary cardiologist or care provider.52 The Turner Syndrome NIH Consensus Study Group recently published more focused guidelines,53 but also with little evidence to support their recommendations. These guidelines recommend a baseline echocardiogram to assess for congenital heart disease and frequent blood pressure screening. For those who have no cardiovascular disease or hypertension, the recommendations include reassessment of the cardiovascular system with a cardiac MRI when sedation is not necessary and repeating either an echocardiogram or MRI every 5–10 years. However, it is unclear if surveillance studies would be able to detect progressive aortic dilatation or imminent dissection. To gain a better understanding of the natural history of aortic dissection in women with TS, we have established an International Turner Syndrome Aortic Dissection Registry (ITSADR, http://www.tssus.org/readweb.asp?wid = 3092).54 Its goal is to identify all girls and women with TS and aortic dissection, to profile their risk factors and to more precisely define the appearance and progression of aortic disease leading to dissection.
All doctors who care for women with TS should be aware of their risk for aortic dissection. The apparent risk during pregnancy for those receiving ART must be recognised and early education of TS women contemplating pregnancy is mandatory. We found that in many of the reported cases and in the two cases presented here, the symptoms developed insidiously over the course of hours to days. A preliminary review of the data of the ITSADR suggests that the signs and symptoms that may herald an aortic dissection include apparently minor complaints such as abdominal pain, “heartburn”, back or shoulder pain, or a change in phonation (due to traction on the recurrent laryngeal nerve). Symptoms that persist should always be taken seriously and warrant complete investigation including transesophageal echocardiography, chest CT or cardiac MR.
Supplementary material is available on the JMG website at http://jmg.bmj.com/supplemental
We wish to thank Dr R Shaughnessy for her careful review of the manuscript and helpful comments, K Gaeta for preparation of the tables and the Turner Syndrome Society of the United States for their support of the International Turner Syndrome Aortic Dissection Registry.
Competing interests: none declared.
- assisted reproductive techniques
- bicuspid aortic valve
- congenital heart disease, HTN, hypertension
- transforming growth factor
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.