Article Text


Homozygosity for a frequent and weakly penetrant predisposing allele at the RET locus in sporadic Hirschsprung disease
  1. A Pelet1,
  2. L de Pontual1,
  3. M Clément-Ziza1,
  4. R Salomon1,
  5. C Mugnier1,
  6. F Matsuda2,
  7. M Lathrop2,
  8. A Munnich1,
  9. J Feingold1,
  10. S Lyonnet1,
  11. L Abel3,
  12. J Amiel1
  1. 1Unité de Recherches sur les Handicaps Génétiques de l’Enfant INSERM U-393 and Département de Génétique, Hôpital Necker-Enfants Malades, Paris, France
  2. 2Centre National de Génotypage, Evry, France
  3. 3Laboratoire de Génétique Humaine des Maladies Infectieuses, INSERM U-550, Hôpital Necker-Enfants Malades, University Paris 5 Medical School, Paris, France
  1. Correspondence to:
 Stanislas Lyonnet
 Département de Génétique, Hôpital Necker-Enfants Malades, 149, rue de Sèvres, 75743 Paris Cedex 15, France;

Statistics from

Hirschsprung disease (HSCR), the most common malformation of the hindgut (1/5000 live births), is a single-field neural crest derived malformation characterised by the absence of enteric ganglia along a variable length of the intestine.1 The genetics of HSCR are complex, considering a skewed sex ratio in favour of females (1/4) and recurrence risk figures whose values depend on the length of the aganglionic segment as well as the gender of affected individuals (mean value of 4%, ranging from 1 to 30%).2,3 All genetic and functional evidence points to the RET proto-oncogene as the major disease causing locus in HSCR. In particular, almost all HSCR families co-segregate with markers of chromosome 10q11.2 where the RET gene locus has been mapped,4–6 although modifier genes are involved.7,8 Nonetheless, in most series worldwide, a mutation within the RET gene coding sequence can be detected in only 40% and 10–20% of familial and sporadic cases, respectively.9–11 These data led to speculation that a frequent hypomorphic allele(s) must exist at the RET locus. To address this question, several groups have used linkage disequilibrium mapping, mostly in case control studies,12–17 taking advantage of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) scattered along the vast genomic domain encompassing the RET locus (55 kb). These studies consistently indicated that a predisposing haplotype is located in the 5′ region of the RET gene, whatever the ethnic background, with some functional data favouring the role of promotor variants.18,19 In order to refine the mapping of predisposing allele(s) at the RET locus and to characterise its genetic behaviour, we used a transmission disequilibrium test (TDT) across the RET gene, in a series of HSCR cases divided according to family type (sporadic or multiplex) and the presence/absence of a RET gene mutation. We found strong association between the disease phenotype and SNPs located 5′ to the RET locus; we also observed highly significant over-transmission of a predisposing SNP haplotype extending over 23 kb from the promoter region to exon 2 and encompassing the large intron 1. Over-transmission was not significant when considering cases with classical RET gene mutations. Conversely, the majority of sporadic HSCR cases with no RET gene mutation showed homozygosity for a low-penetrance predisposing haplotype, suggesting its major involvement in the commonest form of HSCR and its dosage-sensitive effect on the RET signalling pathway. The variable prevalence of the HSCR predisposing RET haplotype in the general population may account for the ethnic dependant prevalence of the disease.


HSCR families

A total of 81 non-syndromic HSCR families, whose parents were available for study, were included. The series was divided into 66 single cases (46 males and 20 females), denoted as sporadic, and 15 one-generation families with at least two affected sibs (a total of 31 affected individuals including 18 males and 13 females), denoted as multiplex. Altogether, short segment and long segment HSCR was found in 45 and 29 cases, respectively, while the length of the aganglionic segment was not known in 23 cases.

Key points

  • The genetics of Hirschsprung disease (HSCR), the most common malformation of the hindgut, are complex.

  • Studies have consistently indicated that a predisposing haplotype is located in the 5′ region of the RET gene.

  • A transmission disequilibrium test across the RET gene was used in a series of 81 HSCR cases divided according to the presence/absence of a RET gene mutation and family type (sporadic or multiplex).

  • A strong association was found between the disease phenotype and single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) located 5′ to the RET locus. Highly significant over-transmission of a predisposing SNP haplotype was also observed, extending over 23 kb from the promoter region to exon 2 and encompassing the large intron 1.

  • Most sporadic HSCR cases with no RET gene mutation showed homozygosity for a low-penetrance predisposing haplotype, opposite to HSCR cases harbouring a RET gene mutation.

RET mutation screening

Blood samples were obtained with informed consent and DNA was extracted according to standard protocols. Probands were sequenced for the coding regions of the RET gene (list of primers is available on request). When a RET gene mutation was identified in the proband, all family members were sequenced for the appropriate exon in order to define their molecular status regarding the mutation.

SNP genotyping

All affected individuals and their parents were also sequenced for regions containing known polymorphisms. We subsequently focused on four SNPs encompassing the 5′ region of the RET locus from the proximal promotor at -5 (SNP-5, G/A, rs109000296) and -1 (SNP-1, C/A, rs109000297), over intron 1 (SNP IVS1, C/T, rs2435357) to exon 2 (G/A, SNP exon 2, rs1800858). All SNPs showed a variant allele with a frequency of at least 25% (table 1) and were tested for Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.

Table 1

 Transmission disequilibrium of RET 5′ SNPs in non-mutated HSCR families

Statistical methods

The role of common RET polymorphisms in susceptibility to HSCR was investigated with a family based association study, which avoids possible confounding of gene-phenotype associations due to inappropriately chosen controls or population substructures. We used the TDT20 to search for a distortion of the transmission of alleles from parents to affected offspring. Data were mainly analysed by the family based method implemented in the FBAT haplotype program.21 This method allows the use of an empirical variance-covariance estimator, which is consistent when sibling marker genotypes are correlated (for example, when the analysis includes multiplex families), and provides valid significance levels for tests of association.22 Data were also analysed by means of conditional logistic regression as described by Schaid and Rowland23. This analysis allowed estimation of odds ratios (ORs) and testing for homogeneity of the regression coefficients associated with RET polymorphisms according to some binary criteria such as gender of affected child, gender of transmitting parent, or family type (sporadic/multiplex). All analyses were performed under an additive model, and ORs correspond to the odds of presenting HSCR for 1-2 children versus 2-2 children, or for 1-1 children versus 1-2 children, in which 1 stands for the predisposing allele and 2 for the protective allele. To test for heterogeneity of the sample according to a binary criterion (for example, sporadic/multiplex families), the analysis was performed on the whole sample (for example, 66 families with no RET gene mutation) and separately on the two subsamples (57 sporadic and nine multiplex families). According to the hypothesis of homogeneity, twice the difference between the likelihood of the whole sample and the summed likelihoods of the two subsamples is distributed as a χ2 with 1 degree of freedom.


RET gene mutation detection

Direct DNA sequencing of the RET coding sequences detected a mutation in 15/81 (18.5%) HSCR index cases. The mutation detection rate is thus as low as reported in previous studies and as expected according to the hypothesis of a frequent hypomorphic mutation at the RET locus. Along the same lines, the mutation detection rate was dependent on family type with 6/15 (40%) and 9/66 (13.6%) in familial and sporadic cases, respectively.

In familial cases, mutations co-segregated with the HSCR phenotype and were mostly missense mutations (G93S, L452P, C620R, M1064T). Of two conservative changes, one has been shown to impair RET function through aberrant splicing (I647I), while the other (P399P) is likely to do so based on prediction programmes. Inherited mutations originated mainly from the mother (4/6 maternal transmissions), in accordance with the lower HSCR penetrance observed in females. In sporadic cases, mutations were either missense (R287M, R330Q, A487T, R873Q, E921K, N1059S) or splicing mutations (IVS-8 -1 G/A, IVS-7 -5 C/T, IVS-10 +1 G/A). Interestingly, 6/9 mutations occurred de novo.

Mutation screening allowed us to further split our sample into two groups: (i) 66 non-mutated families including 57 sporadic cases (38 males and 19 females) and nine multiplex families (all families with two affected children) and (ii) 15 mutated families (nine sporadic cases, four families with two affected children, and two families with three affected children).

SNP and haplotype studies

No SNP marker showed a significant deviation from the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. We concentrated statistical analyses on four SNP markers in a region encompassing 23 kb of the RET genomic domain from the proximal promotor region to exon 2, where the highest association has been reported15–17 and confirmed in the present study. No significant association was found in the 15 HSCR families with a RET gene mutation (nine sporadic, six multiplex), although a trend was observed in favour of a predisposing role of the less common variants of the three SNPs -5, IVS1, and exon 2.

Conversely, in the 66 HSCR families with no RET gene mutation, results were highly significant for the four SNPs (table 1) with ORs up to 8.3 (95% CI 4.0 to 17.2) for SNP-5 (p<10−6). In that sample, homogeneity tests did not show evidence for heterogeneity taking into account neither the gender of the affected child nor the sex of the transmitting parent. However, this test provided evidence for heterogeneity according to family type (sporadic v multiplex; p<0.03 for SNP-5), justifying splitting the sample between non-mutated multiplex and sporadic cases for further analyses.

In the nine non-mutated multiplex HSCR families (table 1), ORs, although greater than 1, were only suggestive of the role of the four SNPs, probably due, at least in part, to the small number of informative families. In contrast, the analysis of SNP transmission in the 57 non-mutated sporadic cases showed a striking over transmission of the rarer alleles of SNP-5, SNP IVS1, and SNP exon 2 with ORs of 18 (5.6–57.5), 13.7 (4.9–37.1), and 7.4 (3.1–17.2), respectively (table 1). A detailed analysis of SNPs -5 and IVS1 showed an overwhelming transmission of the rarer alleles: allele A for SNP-5 and allele T for SNP IVS1, for 54/57 and 55/59 transmissions, respectively (table 2). Moreover, for both these SNPs, each of the children born to heterozygous parents was found to be homozygous for the rare allele (17/17 and 18/18 cases for SNP-5 and SNP IVS1). Accordingly, in contrast with other HSCR sub-groups, no difference could be established between paternal and maternal transmission in this series of 57 non-mutated sporadic cases (table 2).

Table 2

 Transmission of alleles at SNP-5 (G/A, rs109000296) and IVS1 (C/T, rs2435357) to affected child according to genotype in non-mutated simplex families

Based on single-loci SNP genotyping, we studied the most frequent haplotypes composed of the highest associated marker loci (table 3). The three SNPs -5, IVS1, and exon 2 are in very strong linkage disequilibrium and have similar allele frequencies, so that they define only two main haplotypes, A-T-A and G-C-G. SNP-1 has a different frequency from the three other SNPs and association with common allele C of this SNP is very likely due to linkage disequilibrium (allele C is almost always with the predisposing A-T-A haplotype, but due to higher frequency it is also sometimes with the G-C-G haplotype explaining the lower association of SNP-1 with HSCR). When focusing on the three SNPs with similar frequencies, the A-T-A haplotype of rarer alleles conferred a very high predisposition to HSCR in non-mutated sporadic cases (p = 9.10−6). The main effect was due to SNP-5 and SNP IVS1, since the analysis of haplotypes divergent for SNP exon 2 (table 3, upper rows) clearly showed that the A-T haplotype, extending over 10 kb from the promotor to mid-intron 1, was highly predisposing by itself. However, the analysis of haplotypes composed only of the two SNPs -5 and IVS1 did not allow any conclusions to be drawn about a predominant role of either one of these two SNPs (table 3, bottom rows).

Table 3

 Haplotype analysis in the 57 non-mutated HSCR sporadic cases


As expected in a condition with a complex pattern of inheritance, genetic variations at the major locus RET in HSCR may be of low penetrance, are frequent in the general population, and may lie in non-coding sequences, all features opposite to what is observed for mutations in pure Mendelian traits. This would explain why screening in the RET coding sequences failed to demonstrate mutations in more than 15–20% of sporadic cases. In order to refine the mapping of such alleles and characterise their genetic behaviour, we investigated a series of 81 HSCR families using TDT across the vast 5′ genomic domain of the RET locus, from the promotor to exon 2. Our data agree with the hypothesis of a frequent hypomorphic mutation of the RET gene, with the greatest impact in the subgroup of patients with no RET gene mutation identified within the coding sequence (p<10−6). Haplotype studies suggest that this allele is more likely to map 5′ to exon 2 of the RET gene, from the proximal promotor to mid-intron 1.

The vast majority of informative sporadic HSCR cases were found to be homozygous for the predisposing RET gene 5′ haplotype. It is worth remembering that segregation meta-analysis in short segment HSCR, the most represented form in sporadic cases (80%), showed that the best fit were either the autosomal recessive or the multifactorial models.2 We thus propose that the frequent hypomorphic RET allele, located in the 5′ region, results in a dosage-sensitive impairment of the RET signalling pathway, and that homozygosity for that variant is the molecular basis for HSCR in most patients with no coding sequence mutation. Accordingly, the higher penetrance of severe RET gene mutations might explain their higher prevalence in multiplex HSCR families.

The genome-wide scan performed in HSCR sib pairs showed a parent of origin effect at, and only at, the RET locus, with a greater number of maternal transmissions than expected in sibs sharing one allele identical by descent (IBD1).8 In this series, we observed homozygosity for the A-T-A haplotype among non-mutated sporadic cases. We can hypothesise that over maternal IBD1 sharing at the RET locus holds true only among HSCR patients who inherited a classical RET gene mutation as it is more frequently maternal in one-generation familial cases. Conversely, it is striking that a mutation of the coding sequence of the RET gene occurs de novo in over 50% of sporadic HSCR cases (this series and Attié et al9).

Homozygotes for the A-T haplotype at the RET locus are estimated to be 4% of the general population. Homozygosity for the predisposing A-T haplotype may, therefore, be a necessary (although not sufficient) prerequisite for HSCR to occur in most non-mutated sporadic cases. According to both the 100% heritability of HSCR and the observations made in our previous sib-pair study,8 co-inheritance of frequent autosomal dominant predisposing alleles at modifier genes mapping to chromosome 3p21 and 19q12 may be necessary to explain the 1/5000 prevalence of HSCR in Caucasians. Along these lines, it is tempting to speculate that the variable prevalence of HSCR across different ethnic backgrounds may result from the variable frequency of the A-T predisposing haplotype, as suggested by linkage disequilibrium studies at the RET locus.24


We thank the Association Française de la maladie de Hirschsprung for support and participation in the study.


View Abstract


  • This work was supported by European Union grants 2001-01646 and grants from GIS Maladies Rares INSERM-AFM.

  • Competing interests: none declared

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.