Objective: To clarify the genotype–phenotype correlation and elucidate the role of digenic inheritance in cystinuria.
Methods: 164 probands from the International Cystinuria Consortium were screened for mutations in SLC3A1 (type A) and SLC7A9 (type B) and classified on the basis of urine excretion of cystine and dibasic amino acids by obligate heterozygotes into 37 type I (silent heterozygotes), 46 type non-I (hyperexcretor heterozygotes), 14 mixed, and 67 untyped probands.
Results: Mutations were identified in 97% of the probands, representing 282 alleles (86.8%). Forty new mutations were identified: 24 in SLC3A1 and 16 in SLC7A9. Type A heterozygotes showed phenotype I, but mutation DupE5-E9 showed phenotype non-I in some heterozygotes. Type B heterozygotes showed phenotype non-I, with the exception of 10 type B mutations which showed phenotype I in some heterozygotes. Thus most type I probands carried type A mutations and all type non-I probands carried type B mutations. Types B and A mutations contributed to mixed type, BB being the most representative genotype. Two mixed cystinuria families transmitted mutations in both genes: double compound heterozygotes (type AB) had greater aminoaciduria than single heterozygotes in their family.
Conclusions: Digenic inheritance is an exception (two of 164 families), with a limited contribution to the aminoaciduria values (partial phenotype) in cystinuria. Further mutational analysis could focus on one of the two genes (SLC3A1 preferentially for type I and SLC7A9 for type non-I probands), while for mixed probands analysis of both genes might be required, with priority given to SLC7A9.
- DHPLC, denaturing high performance liquid chromatography
- HAT, heteromeric amino acid transporter
- RT-PCR, reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction
- SSCP, single strand conformation polymorphism
- digenic inheritance
Statistics from Altmetric.com
- DHPLC, denaturing high performance liquid chromatography
- HAT, heteromeric amino acid transporter
- RT-PCR, reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction
- SSCP, single strand conformation polymorphism
Cystinuria is an autosomal inherited metabolic disorder characterised by impaired transport of cystine and dibasic amino acids in the proximal renal tubule and the gastrointestinal tract. A high cystine concentration in the urinary tract most often causes the formation of recurring renal cystine stones because of the low solubility of this amino acid. The overall estimated prevalence of the disease is 1/7000 neonates, ranging from 1/2500 neonates in Libyan Jews to 1/100 000 in the Swedish population.1
Cystinuria is classified into three types according to the urine phenotype in heterozygotes: type I (MIM220100), type non-I (MIM600918), and mixed. In type I cystinuria, heterozygotes have a normal pattern of amino acid excretion in the urine (phenotype I), which implies that the disease is transmitted by an autosomal recessive trait. In non-type I cystinuria, heterozygotes have a variable degree of hyperexcretion of cystine and dibasic amino acids (phenotype non-I), indicating that the disease is transmitted in a dominant mode with incomplete penetrance.2 Patients with mixed type cystinuria, who inherit phenotype I and non-I alleles from either parent, have also been described.3
Two genes responsible for cystinuria have been identified. Mutations in SLC3A1, located on chromosome 2p16.3–21 and encoding the b0,+ transporter related protein rBAT, have up to now been shown to cause only type I cystinuria,4–7 and not type non-I.8,9 The gene causing type non-I cystinuria was assigned by linkage analysis to 19q12–13.1,9,10 confined to a 1.3 Mb region11 and identified as SLC7A9,2 the protein product of which (bo,+AT) heterodimerises with rBAT (SLC3A1) in kidney brush border membranes.12 The rBAT/b0,+AT heteromeric complex is responsible for the b0,+ amino acid transport system. This transporter belongs to the heteromeric amino acid transporter (HAT) family, which is formed by a heavy subunit (rBAT or 4F2hc) linked by a disulphide bridge to a range of light subunits (b0,+AT in the case of rBAT).13 At present, 79 SLC3A1 and 50 SLC7A9 mutations—including nonsense, missense, splice site, and frameshift mutations and large rearrangements in both genes—have been described.1,2,6,8,14–27
Despite the classification of the disease described above, we found that some SLC7A9 heterozygotes presented a urinary excretion phenotype near the control range, resembling SLC3A1 heterozygotes that are phenotypically silent.21 Since then, phenotype I heterozygotes carrying SLC7A9 mutations have been reported, and two SLC7A9 mutations (I44T and P261L) have been associated with this phenotype.24,28 These findings make the existing cystinuria classification imprecise because type I cystinuria could be caused by mutations in SLC7A9 instead of SLC3A1. Consequently, a new scheme based only on genetic aspects has recently been proposed28: type A, caused by two mutations in SLC3A1 (rBAT); type B, caused by two mutations in SLC7A9 (bo,+AT); and the possibility of type AB, with one mutation on each of the above genes (that is, cystinuria with digenic inheritance). However, it remains unclear whether type AB implies a digenic inheritance of the disease. Given a similar frequency of mutations in SLC7A9 and SLC3A1,28 we would expect half to be from AB disease. The prevalence of type A disease is similar to that of type B disease, but type AB is extremely rare.28 Two explanations could account for this low prevalence. Type AB patients may have a mild phenotype and escape detection. Alternatively, these individuals may represent type B or type A disease with a coincidental mutation in the other subunit gene. In this case, type AB carriers might be obligate heterozygotes with the possibility of digenic inheritance causing some effects at the phenotypical level.
We focused our study on an exhaustive mutational analysis of a large cohort of patients with extensive genotype–phenotype correlations in order to clarify the cystinuria classification from a genetic point of view. Special emphasis was placed on SLC7A9 alleles that segregate as a silent phenotype in obligate heterozygotes, on mixed cystinuria families, and on possible digenic cases. Here we report the following: 40 new cystinuria specific mutations (24 in SLC3A1 and 16 in SLC7A9); 10 SLC7A9 mutations that associate with phenotype I in heterozygotes; the first SLC3A1 mutation (dupE5-E9) that associates with phenotype non-I in heterozygotes; and two families with mixed cystinuria which carry mutations in both genes and whose amino acid excretion phenotype in urine indicates a contribution of digenic inheritance, described for the first time in cystinuria.
Patients: phenotypic and genetic classification
The institutional review board of the participating centres approved the study and participants gave their informed consent.
Amino acid excretion was determined using morning urine samples or in a 24 hour collection, as described,29 and corrected per gram of creatinine excreted. All subjects who fulfilled the following criteria were included in the study:
urine cystine excretion more than 1040 μmol/g creatinine in a single urine sample or in a 24 hour collection, and at least one identified cystine stone (emitted or surgically removed);
siblings of cystinuria patients, defined above, with the same genetic mutations, even in the absence of stone identification.
We studied 164 independent patients and their relatives of the International Cystinuria Consortium (ICC) database. These probands were from Italy (91), Spain (50), Israel (12), Belgium (4), Portugal (3), Switzerland (2), England (1), and Germany (1). Information on genotype or phenotype for some of these patients is available elsewhere.2,14,15,20–22,28
For phenotype–genotype correlation studies two classifications were established, one based on urinary amino acid excretion and the other on the genetic findings.
Classification based on urinary amino acid excretion
Patients were classified as type I, type non-I, mixed, and untyped on the basis of the urinary excretion values of cystine and dibasic amino acids (lysine, arginine, and ornithine) by the obligate heterozygotes. Thus heterozygotes were considered phenotype non-I when at least two of the indices (cystine, lysine, arginine, ornithine, or the sum of cystine and the three dibasic amino acids in the urine) were above the 95th centile in controls; they were considered phenotype I when these indices were within the control range.
Both parents showed a normal urine amino acid pattern (heterozygotes with excretion values within the control range—that is, phenotype I).
Urinary excretion of both parents was above controls (that is, phenotype non-I heterozygotes). In a few cases, the probands had a urinary amino acid profile similar to the parent transmitting the disease and within the upper range of the non-I heterozygote phenotype. In these cases, when the other parent showed a normal urinary excretion phenotype, the probands were considered to be heterozygotes with non-I cystinuria.
Urinary excretion was above the control values in one of the parents (phenotype non-I) and normal in the other (phenotype I).
Urinary excretion values for one or both parents were not available or were of doubtful classification (that is, inconsistent classification of members of the same family).21
Using these criteria, the 164 studied probands were classified as 37 type I, 46 type non-I, 14 mixed, and 67 untyped (table 1).
Classification based on the genetic findings
Patients were classified as type A, type B, type AB, and type ?? on the basis of the genetic findings.
Probands have mutations in SLC3A1 (A? for one mutated allele identified and AA for two mutated alleles identified).
Probands have mutations in SLC7A9 (B? for one mutated allele identified and, BB and B+ for two mutated alleles identified).
Individuals have one mutation in SLC3A1 and one in SLC7A9. Probands with more than two mutated alleles were classified as AA(B) or BB(A), depending on the distribution of mutations in the two genes.28
No mutations are found in the probands.
Probands and their relatives have been analysed for mutations in SLC3A1, SLC7A9, or in both genes. Mutations in this cohort of patients have been reported previously.2,6,8,14,20–22 Genomic DNA or total RNA was isolated from peripheral blood lymphocytes following standard protocols. Patients with type I or type non-I cystinuria were initially screened for mutations in SLC3A1 and SLC7A9, respectively. Patients not fully genotyped were also analysed for the other cystinuria gene. Untyped patients were analysed for both genes as well. Mutational screening of the whole coding region, all intron/exon boundaries, and some intron sequences (on average 50 base pairs (bp) on each side of the exons) was carried out by polymerase chain reaction (PCR), reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) (when RNA samples were available), single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP), or Southern blot as described elsewhere,14,21 and by denaturing high performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) or semiquantitative multiplex PCR as described below. Direct sequencing was also carried out in all the individuals analysed to confirm the results obtained, to identify the mutated position in the gene, and to screen for mutations not detectable by these techniques. Southern blotting or semiquantitative multiplex PCR was used in patients with no mutations or only one mutation found with the other techniques, including direct sequencing. All the mutations described were checked on 100 control chromosomes to discard polymorphisms. Mutations listed or newly described here follow the nomenclature of the Human Genome Variation Society (www.genomic.unimelb.edu.au/mdi/mutnomen/). All new mutations have been introduced in the HGMDB database (www.hgmd.org/).
Samples for DHPLC analysis were amplified in a final reaction volume of 50 μl, using 100 ng genomic DNA, 10× PCR buffer with 15 mM MgCl2 (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, California, USA), 200 μM dNTPs, 0.30 μM primer, and 1.5 units AmpliTaq Gold ™ (Applied Biosystems). PCR cycling conditions consisted of an initial denaturation step at 95°C for 12 minutes followed by 35 cycles at 94°C for 30 seconds; the annealing temperature range was 55–57°C for 30 seconds, followed by 72°C for 30 seconds, and ending with a final elongation step at 72°C for eight minutes. DHPLC analysis was carried out on an automated DHPLC instrument (Transgenomic Inc, Santa Clara, California, USA).
Heteroduplex formation was induced by mixing an aliquot of unpurified PCR amplicon from patients and wild type sample in a 1:1 ratio. The mixed samples were heated to 95°C for five minutes and cooled slowly over 25 minutes to 35°C. Usually, 7–10 μl of reannealed DNA duplexes were injected onto the column and then run at predetermined temperatures on the WAVE® system. The resolution temperature (Tr) for each of the 12 PCR amplicons of genomic DNA from SLC3A1 and 13 from SLC7A9 analysed was predicted by using WaveMaker software (Transgenomic). The primers used for PCR amplification and DHPLC conditions are reported in table 1s in Supplementary Material, available online at the JMG website (www.jmg.com/supplemental). Fragments that showed variation in retention time or chromatogram shape from that of an unaffected control amplicon were then sequenced following the Big Dye Terminator protocol (PE-ABI, Foster City, California, USA) and analysed on an ABI 3100 DNA sequencer (Applied Biosystems).
Semiquantitative multiplex PCR analysis in SLC7A9
We undertook multiplex analysis for SLC7A9 in 13 patients from independent families in which no mutations or only one mutation had been found with the other techniques. This method was used previously for the analysis of large rearrangements in SLC3A1.20 Primer pairs for each of the 13 exons of SLC7A9 were used (table 2s in Supplementary Material). One primer of each pair was labelled with FAM fluorescence (Invitrogen, San Diego, California, USA). As an external double dose control, a primer pair amplifying exon 5 from DSCR1 (Down syndrome critical region gene 1) in chromosome 21 was added, together with the other set of 13 primer pairs. In a final volume of 20 μl, we mixed 100 ng DNA, 0.2 mM dNTPs, 1.5 U Taq (Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany), 0.01% gelatine, PCR buffer with 1.5 mM MgCl2, and a mix of primers. The reaction started with an initial denaturation of five minutes at 94°C, followed by 23 cycles of 94°C for 25 seconds, 58°C for 25 seconds, and 72°C 25 seconds. A final extension of seven minutes at 72°C was used. The PCR products were loaded on a 48-well acrylamide gel together with an external fluorescent size standard (TAMRA-Gs500) and run in an ABI PRISM 377 DNA sequencer (Applied Biosystems). The results were processed by GENESCAN™ software (fig 1s in Supplementary Material). To confirm the duplication of exon 12 in family 73, we amplified a 518 bp fragment (only in the carriers) with 5 pmol of primers F11 (5′-ATGATTGAAATTGGAGGAGGG-3′) and R10d (5′- CCTAATAAGCAGTCTACAAGA-3′), following standard methods, for 36 cycles of 94°C 30 seconds, 58°C 30 seconds, 74°C 30 seconds, plus five minutes at 74°C. To confirm the deletion in family 94, we amplified a 251 bp fragment using 5 pmol of primer F13 (5′- CAGACCATACTGTAAAGGACC -3′) and R13 (5′- CGTGGGCATGTGTCCTCCT -3′), following standard methods, for 36 cycles, 10 cycles of 94°C 30 seconds, 60°C 30 seconds, 74°C 30 seconds, 26 cycles of 90°C 30 seconds, 59°C 30 seconds, 74°C 30 seconds, plus seven minutes at 74°C.
Identification of 40 new cystinuria specific mutations in SLC3A1 and SLC7A9
Mutational analysis was carried out exhaustively in 164 families that transmit cystinuria and which are included in the ICC database. We identified 24 new mutations in SLC3A1 and 16 in SLC7A9 (table 2). None of these mutations was identified in 100 control chromosomes tested (data not shown). They included five frameshift mutations (three in SLC3A1 and two in SLC7A9) and one nonsense mutation in SLC3A1 which produce early stop codons; seven splice mutations (one in SLC3A1 and six in SLC7A9); 22 changes that affect single amino acid residues (16 and five missense mutations in SLC3A1 and SLC7A9, respectively, and one deletion of a single amino acid residue in SLC3A1); two silent changes affecting the coding region of the gene (one in SLC3A1 and one in SLC7A9); and three large rearrangements (one in SLC3A1 and two in SLC7A9).
The two large SLC7A9 rearrangements were detected in two patients by semiquantitative multiplex PCR analysis: a 5 kb deletion (c.1224+4166_c.1399+119del) and a 5 kb duplication (c.1224+4166_c.1399+119dup), both affecting exon 12, originated by the crossing over of two 195 bp sequences which differ by one nucleotide and are separated by 4778 bp (fig 2s in Supplementary Material). The abnormal multiplex exon pattern in these two patients is shown in fig 3s in Supplementary Material. These two mutations were confirmed by PCR primers which specifically amplify the mutated allele in both cases (fig 2s in Supplementary Material). The protein product expected from the 5 kb duplication would have a frameshift from residue K386 with the addition of 78 missense residues before the first stop codon (p.K386fsX78). The 5 kb deletion affects intron 11 and the first 100 bp of the 175 bp of exon 12, and most probably results in the skipping of exon 12, because the donor splice site is deleted and there are no potential donor sites around. The protein product of this deletion would have a frameshift from residue V409, adding nine missense residues before the first stop codon (p.V409fsX9), and lacking the last transmembrane domains XI and XII. However, RNA was not available from these patients to confirm the predicted changes.
Two of the splice mutations were localised outside the splice consensus sequences, and were checked to produce aberrant splicing by RT-PCR:
586C→T in SLC7A9 is a silent exonic mutation that creates alternative donor site 20 bp upstream of the consensus donor site. The resultant RNA (r.585_604del) is expected to produce a frameshift from residue L196 of b0+AT (p.L196_G202delfsX5) (data not shown);
c.1012–23C→G in SLC3A1 localises in intron 5 and produces the skipping of exon 6 (r.1012_1136del), which is expected to result in a frameshift from residue D338 of rBAT (p.D338_Y378delfsX5) (data not shown).
The rest of the new splice mutations affect the consensus donor or acceptor splice site sequences, thereby indicating aberrant splicing.
The two silent mutations located in exonic regions (that is, no amino acid change) are predicted to create splicing defects, but it was not possible to check this by RT-PCR:
c.171C→T in SLC7A9 may create an alternative donor splice site 64 bp upstream of the consensus donor site;
c.1035G→A in SLC3A1 localizes in a putative exonic splicing enhancer (ESE) for SF2/ASF with a score prediction of 2.36, while the mutation reduces the ESE prediction to 0.44 (that is, below threshold = 1.96), suggesting aberrant splicing.30
In the ICC cohort of patients M467T is the most common SLC3A1 mutation, accounting for 26.4% of the total type A alleles, and together with T216M (6.4%), DupE5-E9 (4.0%), c.163delC (4.0%), R270X (4.0%), and c.765+1G→T (3.2%) represents 48.0% of total type A alleles (table 3s in Supplementary Material). For SLC7A9 the most common alleles are: G105R (27.4%), R333W (12.1%), V170M (11.5%) (17 alleles in the Libyan-Jewish population and one in the Italian population), c.614dupA (the Human Genome Variation Society nomenclature for mutation c.800–801insA) (7.0%) (eight alleles from Spain, two from Italy, and one from England), A182T (5.1%), T123M (3.8%) and c.605–3C→A (2.5%), which account for 69.4% of total type B alleles. Other SLC3A1 or SLC7A9 mutations were identified in three or fewer independent alleles.
The new mutations, together with those previously reported by the ICC (table 3s in Supplementary Material) and by others,15–19,23–27 make a total of 103 and 66 mutations identified in SLC3A1 and SLC7A9, respectively: 28 frameshift (14 in SLC3A1 and 14 in SLC7A9), seven nonsense (five in SLC3A1 and two in SLC7A9), 18 splice (seven in SLC3A1 and 11 in SLC7A9), 89 missense (59 in SLC3A1 and 30 in SLC7A9), two silent (one in SLC3A1 and one in SLC7A9), five deletions or insertions of a single amino acid residue (one in SLC3A1 and four in SLC7A9), 18 large rearrangements (14 in SLC3A1 and four in SLC7A9), and two cystinuria specific sequence variants in the promoter region of SLC3A1.
Distribution of cystinuria alleles per phenotype and genotype
The 164 cystinuria probands studied were classified on the basis of the urinary excretion of cystine and dibasic amino acids in obligate heterozygotes (urine phenotype) (see Methods) and also following the genetic classification proposed by Dello Strologo et al28 (type A, mutations in SLC3A1; type B, mutations in SLC7A9) (table 1). Potentially, these probands represent 325 cystinuria independent alleles (three probands were classified as non-I cystinuria heterozygotes, see below). In all, 282 alleles were characterised (that is, 86.8%). Thus 13.2% of the potential alleles were not identified. The alleles explained were 90.5% in type I probands, 87.6% in non-I, 89.3% in mixed, and 83.6% in untyped. In 126 probands (76.8%) we identified two mutations, in 33 (20.1%) one mutation, and in five (3.0%) no mutations. Of the fully explained probands, 56 (34.1%) and 68 (41.5%) carry two mutations in SLC3A1 (probands AA) and SLC7A9 (probands BB and B+) respectively.
Table 3 describes the type of mutation identified in each allele of the 14 mixed cystinuria probands, which potentially represent 14 phenotype I and 14 phenotype non-I alleles. This table shows that all the possible genotypes in cystinuria are found in mixed families, BB being the most representative genotype.
Data in tables 1 and 3 allow calculation of the number of explained alleles classified by phenotype and genotype (tables 4 and 5): 89.7% and 88.3% of the phenotype I and non-I alleles have been explained, respectively. Alleles identified as type A and type B were 125 and 157, respectively. This represents 44.3% (type A) and 55.7% (type B) of the alleles identified.
Most type A alleles segregate with cystinuria type I, but type A mutations explained phenotype non-I in obligate heterozygotes in three mixed cystinuria families (tables 1 and 3). To our knowledge this is the first description of SLC3A1 mutations with phenotype non-I in heterozygotes. Type B alleles segregated mainly with phenotype non-I (tables 1 and 3). However, in agreement with previous reports,24,28SLC7A9 mutations also segregated with phenotype I in heterozygotes. Thus one type I proband carries two type B mutations (BB), and two other type I probands carry one type B mutation (B?) (table 1). Moreover, the phenotype I allele in eight mixed cystinuria probands was explained by type B mutations (seven BB and one BB(A) probands; table 3).
SLC3A1 dupE5-E9 show phenotype non-I in most of the heterozygotes
Recently, Schmidt et al27 described a cystinuria specific SLC3A1 rearrangement (c.(891+1524_1618–1600)dup; that is, duplication of exons 5 to 9; dupE5-E9) that results in the in frame duplication of amino acid residues E298 to D539 of the rBAT protein (p.E298_D539dup) as demonstrated by our own RNA studies (not shown) and by Schmidt et al.27 Five probands of the ICC database carry this duplication. Four are compound heterozygotes with SLC3A1 mutations (M467T, Spanish family 79; R452W, Spanish family 14; c.765+1G→T; Spanish family 92; c.1749delA, Belgian family 106). Two patients in the fifth family (Italian family 77) are compound heterozygotes with SLC3A1 mutations dupE5-E9 and M467T, and also carry the SLC7A9 mutation c.789+2T→C in one allele (fig 2B). Amino acid levels in urine for six single dupE5-E9 carriers of families were available (table 6). Interestingly, four of these carriers (F14-C119, F77-SR, F79-A145, and F79-A148) showed excretion of cystine and dibasic amino acids within the range of phenotype non-I heterozygotes. In contrast, carrier F106-D18 showed amino acid levels in urine within the control range like most of SLC3A1 heterozygotes. Cystine in urine was not analysed in the other carrier in this family but the urine excretion of the other amino acids was within the control range, indicating phenotype I. To our knowledge dupE5-E9 is the first SLC3A1 mutation that shows phenotype non-I in heterozygotes.
SLC7A9 mutations that show phenotype I in heterozygotes
SLC7A9 mutations with phenotype I in heterozygotes are shown in table 7. A182T, G105R, V170M, and c.614dupA are common SLC7A9 mutations (table 3s in Supplementary Material). Six of the 11 A182T carriers showed phenotype I as the average urine levels of cystine, lysine, and the sum of the four amino acids were below the fifth centile of values in heterozygotes B+ with phenotype non-I (table 7). In contrast, the other five A182T carriers had amino acid levels in the urine above the 95th centile in controls (phenotype non-I) and within the range of values for B+ heterozygotes with phenotype non-I. The proportion of heterozygotes with phenotype I carrying the other common SLC7A9 mutations was variable: T123M (two of four), V170M (four of 16), c.614dupA (one of 19), and G105R (one of 32). In contrast, carriers of the common and severe mutation R333W21 showed phenotype non-I in all cases. Moreover we describe carriers of six uncommon SLC7A9 mutations that also show phenotype I (G63R, A126T, G195R, Y232C, and W69X) (table 7). Interestingly, in some of the SLC7A9 heterozygotes with phenotype I, urine levels of cystine but not of dibasic amino acids were above than 95th centile of control values and within the lower range of values of B+ heterozygotes (phenotype non-I). All phenotype I alleles with common or uncommon SLC7A9 mutations belong to mixed (and untyped) families except for family F112, which transmit type I cystinuria (the proband is a G105R/T123M compound heterozygote).
Urine amino acid excretion in patients with cystinuria classified by genotype and phenotype
Table 8 shows the excretion of cystine and dibasic amino acids in urine of patients in relation to their allele genotype (A or B) and their cystinuria type. Three groups of patients were numerous enough for statistical comparisons: patients AA with type I (n = 34), patients BB with type non-I (n = 37), and patients BB with mixed type (n = 11). The average urine levels of cystine and the three dibasic amino acids, as well as the 5th and 95th centile of these values, were very similar for patients AA with type I and BB with type non-I. This is shown graphically for the sum of the urine excretion of the four amino acids in fig 1. The average and the 95th centile of urine excretion of lysine, arginine, and ornithine, and the sum of the four amino acids were lower in patients BB with mixed type than in patients AA with type I and patients BB with type non-I. Similarly, patients BB with type I cystinuria showed urine excretion values for dibasic amino acids within the lower limit of excretion values in patients BB with type non-I and AA with type I. In contrast, urine cystine levels were very similar in all these groups. This probably reflects the fact that most of the cystinuria patients reached the limit of solubility of cystine in urine (300 mg/l or 1.2 mM),31 and this resulted in an underestimation of this amino acid in the urine when the sample was not previously diluted to dissolve cystine microcrystals. Indeed, the 95th centile of cystine levels in urine in these four groups of patients (up to ∼3400 μmol/g creatinine) represents 3.4 mM, assuming 1 g creatinine/litre of urine.
Three patients with cystine urolithiasis were classified as heterozygotes for SLC7A9 mutations (B+) on the basis of their urine amino acid concentrations (table 8, fig 1), which were similar to that of the parent transmitting the mutation (data not shown) and within the range of excretion of heterozygotes B+ with phenotype non-I (table 7). Moreover, these three patients excreted less arginine and ornithine than the fifth centile of patients BB with mixed cystinuria (table 8).
Only three AA patients with mixed cystinuria were identified in the ICC database (table 8, fig 1). The two patients with higher amino acid excretion values are siblings (family 14) and compound heterozygotes (dupE5-E9/R452W), and one of them had very substantial aminoaciduria. The expected severe defect of mutations R452W (that is, a non-conservative amino acid substitution) and dupE5-E9 (the only SLC3A1 mutation that associated with phenotype non-I in heterozygotes) might contribute to the severe urine phenotype in this patient. The third patient (family 79), who had the lowest amino acid excretion values in urine (within the lower range of patients AA (type I)), is a compound heterozygote (dupE5-E9/M467T). Patient homozygotes for M467T or compound heterozygotes carrying M467T showed lower amino acid excretion values in urine (mean (SEM), μmol/g creatinine, n = 20: 1414 (136) for cystine, 5753 (669) for lysine, 1718 (404) for arginine, 1227 (160) for ornithine, and 9859 (1222) for the sum of the four amino acids) than AA patients without this mutation (n = 33: 2376 (291) for cystine, 9173 (835) for lysine, 3655 (378) for arginine, 3526 (505) for ornithine, and 18 730 (1517) for the sum of the four amino acids). Indeed, three patients homozygous for M467T had amino acid concentrations in urine (sum of the four amino acids: 5613, 6433, and 8113 μmol/g creatinine6) that were among the lowest in patients AA. Thus the mild phenotype of M467T might contribute to the low amino acid excretion values in the compound heterozygote dupE5-E9/M467T.
Digenic inheritance causing a partial phenotype in two cystinuria families
Patient BB(A) (family 35; fig 2A) is a compound heterozygote of SLC7A9 mutations (Y232C/G105R) that also carries the SLC3A1 mutation M467T. Mutations Y232C and M467T showed phenotype I, whereas G105R showed phenotype non-I in the heterozygotes of this family. Patient BB(A) was then classified as presenting mixed cystinuria. This patient had very low urine amino acid levels, which were similar to the fifth centile of these values in patients BB (type non-I). Two members of this family are double carriers (AB) (G105R/+ for SLC7A9 and M467T/+ for SLC3A1). Digenic cystinuria without urolithiasis is suggested in these two double carriers, as they had higher urinary excretion values than the single heterozygotes (G105R/+ or M467T/+) within the family. Patient AA(B) (family 77; figs 1 and 2B) had very high amino acid concentrations in the urine and at the time of this study her sister was on dialysis. Both carry SLC3A1 mutations dupE5-E9 and M467T and the SLC7A9 mutation c.789+2T→C. M467T showed phenotype I, whereas dupE5-E9 showed phenotype non-I in the heterozygotes identified in this family. Patients AA(B) were then classified as having mixed cystinuria. The type B mutation seems to contribute to the severe phenotype in these patients. Thus one of these patients (M467T/dupE5-E9 and c.789+2T→C/+) excreted larger amounts of amino acids than patient M467T/dupE5-E9 (family 79) (compare patient AA(B) and patient AA (mixed) with the lowest aminoaciduria in table 8 and fig 1). In contrast, the mild mutation M467T did not seem to aggravate the urine phenotype of the double carrier in family 77 (M467T/+ and c.2789+2T→C/+). Thus the aminoaciduria in this double carrier was lower than that of two single c.782+2T→C heterozygotes (family 58), which had the greatest aminoaciduria (the sum of the urine levels of the four amino acids was 8112 and 8307 mmol/g creatinine) among the heterozygotes B+ in our database.
We describe 40 new cystinuria mutations (24 in SLC3A1 and 16 in SLC7A9) which bring the total number of cystinuria specific mutations identified to 103 in SLC3A1 and 66 in SLC7A9. The mutations include missense, nonsense, splicing defects, frameshift, deletions and insertions of a single amino acid residue, and large rearrangements. To our knowledge, the present study represents the largest percentage of cystinuria alleles explained in any large cohort of patients reported (86.8%; 282 of 325 alleles). In a recent study,27 only 64.7% of the alleles were explained (75 of 116 alleles). In the ICC database, the coverage of identified alleles is similar for probands with different cystinuria types (on average 89.3%). The percentage of explained alleles in untyped patients was lower (83.6%), which might be attributed to the presence of SLC7A9 carriers with cystine urolithiasis.
The greater number of characterised alleles allows a general summary of the cystinuria mutations in the ICC database, which includes patients of mainly Italian, Spanish, or Libyan-Jewish origin. Type A (SLC3A1) and type B (SLC7A9) mutations accounted for 44.3% and 55.7% of the explained alleles, respectively. To our knowledge, these are the first relative frequencies of type A and type B alleles to be reported, but they must be viewed with caution. The ICC database is not a registry, as we did not collect all possible cases.28 The ICC was very active in collecting phenotype non-I cystinuria cases in order to identify the SLC7A9 gene,2,10,11 and the prevalence of type B mutations might be overestimated. M467T and G105R were the most common type A and type B mutations (26.4% and 27.4% of each type of alleles, respectively). This is consistent with reports on other smaller cohorts of patients with cystinuria.16,23,25 The five most common type A and type B mutations accounted for 44.8% and 63.1% of the identified alleles of each type (A or B), respectively. Moreover, 55 SLC3A1 and 45 SLC7A9 mutations covered the 125 type A and the 157 type B explained alleles, respectively, showing that SLC3A1 has greater genetic heterogeneity than SLC7A9 in the ICC database.
The present search for mutations was very careful (SSCP, DHPLC, direct sequencing, and specific search for large rearrangements of SLC3A1 and SLC7A9) and covered the whole coding region and all intron/exon boundaries. The unexplained cystinuria alleles (13.2%) may be the result of mutations in intronic or promoter regions not yet identified in the two known cystinuria genes or they may reflect unidentified genes. Also, SLC3A1 or SLC7A9 polymorphisms in combination with cystinuria specific mutations might result in full blown cystinuria, for the following reasons.
First, the promoter region of these genes was not analysed in this study, but a small contribution of mutations in these regions is expected. Indeed, two cystinuria specific sequence variants in the promoter region of SLC3A1 have been reported,19 but functional studies should be done to confirm these mutations.
Second, intronic mutations affecting sequences other than the splice-site consensus ones could explain these alleles, but RNA studies would be necessary to assess this.
Third, a third cystinuria gene cannot be discounted but it would be relegated to a very small proportion of patients (no mutations were found in any of the two cystinuria genes in only 3% of the probands), and seems improbable. Co-immunoprecipitation studies and the SLC7A9 KO model showed that the protein products of SLC3A1 (rBAT) and SLC7A9 (b0,+AT) heterodimerise in mouse kidney brush border membranes, but a significant part of rBAT heterodimerises with an unknown light subunit (X).12,32 This may also be true in human kidney brush borders.12 Therefore, the gene coding for X could be a candidate for cystinuria. However, the similar hyperexcretion of amino acids detected in urine of patients AA and BB does not support this hypothesis. If X were coded by a cystinuria gene one would expect a greater degree of aminoaciduria in patients AA than in patients BB—b0,+AT mutations would affect system b0,+ only, whereas rBAT mutations would affect system b0,+ and the transport activity of the rBAT/X heteromeric complex.
Finally, SLC3A1 or SLC7A9 polymorphisms in combination with cystinuria specific mutations might result in full blown cystinuria, as has been suggested.33 Cystinuria association and functional analysis of these polymorphisms are required to demonstrate their contribution to the disease.
Some heterozygotes for the SLC3A1 mutation dupE5-E9—which results in the duplication of the rBAT fragment E298-D539—presented with phenotype non-I (table 6). All other SLC3A1 mutations, including very severe ones (for example, c.163delC which produces a frameshift with an early stop codon, eliminating the transmembrane and the extracellular domains of rBAT (p.Q55fsX51); or c.431_2055del, which eliminates 80% of the rBAT residues towards the C-terminus (p.G144_C685del)) showed phenotype I.6,18,22,25,34 This indicates that mutation dupE5-E9 has a dominant negative effect on the rBAT/b0,+AT heteromeric complex.
Because 14% of SLC7A9 heterozygotes showed phenotype I we proposed a classification of cystinuria on the basis of genotype rather than phenotype.28 Rozen and coworkers identified two type I heterozygotes carrying the SLC7A9 mutations I44T and P261L, respectively.24 Here we report 10 more of these SLC7A9 mutations. Four showed phenotype I in several carriers (A182T, T123M, G63R, and V170M). Mutations A182T and T123M affect non-conserved amino acid residues in the family of the light subunits of HATs. Moreover, A182T is a mild mutation with aberrant trafficking to the plasma membrane35 and substantial residual transport activity (60%).21 Similarly, A126T and P261L, with a single type I carrier identified, also involve non-conserved amino acid residues. Interestingly, patients BB with mixed or type I cystinuria (that is, with type B heterozygotes with phenotype I in their families) also presented with a mild urine phenotype (table 8 and fig 1). This agrees with the mild urine phenotype reported for patients with mixed cystinuria.36 Seven of the 11 patients BB (mixed) and the patient BB (type I) carry A182T or T123M. The mild amino acid transport defect of these mutations could be the underlying cause of the mild urine phenotype of these patients. In contrast, other mutations with phenotype I in heterozygotes (I44T, G63R, G105R, V170M, G195R, and Y232C) involved fully conserved amino acid residues or resulted in large protein changes (W69X, with b0,+AT truncated after the first transmembrane domain; c.614dupA, a mutation shown by mRNA studies to result in skipping of exons 5 and 6 (r.479_709del), producing a frameshift at residue 160 (p.L160fsX1); data not shown). Moreover, G105R and V170M have little amino acid transport function.21 Interestingly, a very small proportion of heterozygotes who carry severe and common mutations like c.614dupA (one of 19 carriers) and G105R (one of 32 carriers) had phenotype I, but one quarter of the V170M heterozygotes manifested phenotype I (all from a Libyan Jewish origin). This indicates that, in addition to the residual functional activity of b0,+AT mutants, other factors (environmental or genetic) contribute to the urine phenotype of carriers of SLC7A9 mutations.
Only three patients in the ICC database are double compound heterozygotes with mutations in both genes (two patients with mutations M467T and dupE5-E9 (AA), and c.789+2T→C (B), and one patient with mutations Y232C and G105R (BB), and M467T (A)). One patient AA(B) has previously been reported but with no description of the associated urine phenotype.37 The degree of aminoaciduria of these type of patient and their relatives in the ICC database indicates that digenic inheritance in cystinuria has only a partial effect on the phenotype, restricted to a variable impact on the aminoaciduria, for the following reasons.
First, in family 77, the severe aminoaciduria in one of the patients AA(B) indicates that the type B mutation c.789+2T→C, associated with high aminoaciduria in heterozygotes, contributes to the urine phenotype; no information is available from the other patient AA(B) as she is on dialysis.
Second, in family 35, the mild aminoaciduria of patient BB(A) indicates that M467T, associated with mild aminoaciduria in homozygotes and compound heterozygotes, does not contribute to the urine phenotype in the patient, but two double compound heterozygotes in this family (M467T/+, G105R/+; that is, AB) showed greater aminoaciduria than the single heterozygotes within the family, suggesting a contribution of both mutations to the urine phenotype.
Third, none of the individuals AB had cystine urolithiasis. Given that almost 90% of the alleles of the ICC cohort of patients have been identified, and that the frequency of type A and B alleles is similar in this cohort, if digenic inheritance was the rule in cystinuria, we would expect 25% AA patients, 25% BB patients, and 50% AB patients. Furthermore, the few AB individuals identified did not have cystine urolithiasis. This indicates that digenic inheritance, affecting the phenotype, is an exception in cystinuria. However, we cannot discard the possibility that some combinations of mutations A and B produce enough cystine hyperexcretion to cause urolithiasis. In this regard, the urolithiasis activity of individuals B/+, with a low penetrance for cystine urolithiasis (three of 192 genotyped patients; 1.7%), might be aggravated by the addition of the effect of one type A allele.
A working hypothesis on the biogenesis of the rBAT/b0,+AT heterodimer and the urine phenotypes in cystinuria may explain the apparent lack of full digenic inheritance in cystinuria. In the first place, the rBAT protein is produced in excess in the kidney, and therefore an rBAT mutation in heterozygosis (for example, the mouse cystinuria model with the SLC3A1 mutation D140G38 and all human cystinuria rBAT mutations with the exception of dupE5-E9) does not lead to hyperexcretion of amino acids (phenotype I). Secondly; b0,+AT controls the expression of the functional rBAT/b0,+AT heterodimeric complex—interaction with b0,+AT stabilises rBAT and the excess of rBAT is degraded, as shown in transfected cells.35,39 As a result, a half dose of b0,+AT (heterozygotes of severe human SLC7A9 mutations or of the SLC7A9 knockout mice32) results in a significant decrease in the expression of rBAT/b0,+AT heterodimer complex (system b0,+), which causes hyperexcretion of cystine and dibasic amino acids. In this scenario, the lack of a full phenotype because of digenic inheritance indicates that in double heterozygotes (AB), the mutated rBAT, with trafficking defects,18,40,41 does not interact with, or does not compromise, the heterodimerisation and trafficking to the plasma membrane of the half dose of wild type b0,+AT with the half dose of wild type rBAT. Thus AB individuals behave as B heterozygotes with a variable degree of aminoaciduria, which could be greater than that of the single heterozygotes within the family, depending on the particular combination of mutations. We are currently studying the hypothesis that the phenotype non-I associated to the SLC3A1 mutation dupE5-E9 reflects heterodimerisation with b0,+AT, which results in a non-active heteromeric complex.
We thank the families who participated in this study. We also thank L Sánchez for technical help and Tanya Yates for editorial help. This work was supported in part by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology (PM99–0172-CO-01/02 and SAF2003–08940–01/02), BIOMED (BMH4 CT98–3514), the Spanish Institut de Salud Carlos III (networks G03/054, C03/07, and C03/08), the Generalitat de Catalunya (2001 SGR00399; 2001 SGR00118), and the Marató de TV3 (98130) to VN and MP, by the Comissionat per a Universitats i Recerca to MP, and by the Ministero Italiano della Salute (Ricerca Corrente 2001) to LZ. MF-L was a recipient of a predoctoral fellowship from the Comissió Interdepartamental de Recerca i Innovació Tecnològica from the Generalitat de Catalunya. MJ-V was supported by the BIOMED BMH4 CT98–3514 and EUGINDAT (LSHM-CT-2003-502852).
Web-only Tables and Figures
The tables and figures are available as downloadable PDFs (printer friendly files).
If you do not have Adobe Reader installed on your computer,
you can download this free-of-charge, please Click here
Files in this Data Supplement:
- [View PDF] - Table 1s Primers used to amplify the SLC7A9 exons for DHPLC analysis
- [View PDF] - Table 2s Primers used to amplify the SLC7A9 exons together with the external double dose control DSCR1 gene
- [View PDF] - Table 3 Cystinuria-specific mutated alleles identified in the 164 probands studied of the International Cystinuria Consortium (ICC) database
- [View PDF] - Figure 1s Semi-quantitative Multiplex PCR analysis of SLC7A9 in controls
- [View PDF] - Figure 2s Genomic region of SLC7A9 rearranged in patients with the 5 kb deletion and the 5 kb duplication
- [View PDF] - Figure 3s Results of two semi-quantitative multiplex PCR analysis in families 73 and 94
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.