Article Text


Variable penetrance of a familial progressive necrotising encephalopathy due to a novel tRNAIle homoplasmic mutation in the mitochondrial genome
  1. A Limongelli1,*,
  2. J Schaefer2,*,
  3. S Jackson2,
  4. F Invernizzi1,
  5. Y Kirino3,
  6. T Suzuki3,
  7. H Reichmann2,
  8. M Zeviani1
  1. 1Unit of Molecular Neurogenetics–Pierfranco and Luisa Mariani Centre for the Study of Children’s Mitochondrial Disorders, National Neurological Institute “Carlo Besta”, Milan, Italy
  2. 2Neurological Clinics, School of Medicine, Technical University, Dresden, Germany
  3. 3Department of Integrated Biosciences, Graduate School of Frontier Sciences, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
  1. Correspondence to:
 M Zeviani
 MD, PhD, Unit of Molecular Neurogenetics, National Neurological Institute “Carlo Besta”, via Temolo 4, 20133 Milan, Italy;;


Introduction: We present a family comprising a clinically normal mother and two daughters, each with severe encephalopathy with onset in late childhood. A third daughter had died previously of an earlier onset but neuropathologically similar disease.

Methods: Sequence analysis of the entire mtDNA was carried out in muscle, fibroblasts, and lymphocytes of the affected daughters and unaffected mother. Biochemical analysis of individual respiratory chain enzymes was performed on the same tissues, and on several transmitochondrial cybrid clones containing the nucleus of a 143B.206 osteosarcoma cell line and the mutant mtDNA.

Results: Genetic analyses revealed in both daughters and mother the presence of a novel mutation in the tRNAIle gene of mtDNA, which was homoplasmic in fibroblasts, lymphocytes, and skeletal muscle of the two patients. It was also homoplasmic in fibroblast and skeletal muscle samples of the mother, and approximately 97% heteroplasmic in her lymphocytes. Combined defects of complexes I and IV of the mitochondrial respiratory chain were found not only in fibroblasts of the two probands, but surprisingly also in those of their clinically unaffected mother. The respiratory chain defect segregated in transmitochondrial cybrids containing the nucleus of a 143B.206 osteosarcoma cell line and the mutant mtDNA, indicating that the latter was responsible for the biochemical phenotype.

Discussion: Our results support the concept that homoplasmic mutations in tRNA genes can be responsible for mitochondrial disorders characterised by extremely variable penetrance. Albeit still unexplained, this phenomenon has important consequences in the nosological characterisation, clinical management, and genetic counselling of mitochondrial disorders.

  • cybrid
  • encephalopathy
  • homoplasmy
  • mitochondrial genome
  • mutation
  • BAEP, brainstem auditory evoked potential
  • LHON, Leber’s hereditary optic neuropathy
  • MEP, motor evoked potential
  • MIHL, maternally inherited hearing loss
  • OXPHOS, oxidative phosphorylation
  • PCR, polymerase chain reaction
  • RFLP restriction fragment length polymorphism
  • SSEP, somatosensory evoked potentials

Statistics from

Mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) account for a substantial fraction of mitochondrial disorders, a group of clinical syndromes associated with abnormalities of the terminal component of mitochondrial energy metabolism—that is, oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS).1 Oxidative phosphorylation is carried out by the four enzyme complexes of the respiratory chain (complexes I-IV), plus the ATP synthase complex (complex V). MtDNA contains the genetic information to encode 13 polypeptides, which are essential components of complexes I, III, IV, and V, and most of the RNA apparatus necessary for their in situ translation—that is, 22 transfer RNA (tRNA) and two ribosomal RNA (rRNA).2 Mutations of mtDNA include large scale rearrangements, which are usually sporadic, and point mutations, which are usually transmitted through the maternal lineage. Whilst large scale rearrangements are invariably heteroplasmic—a state in which both mutant and wild type mtDNA species co-exist in the same cell or tissue—point mutations may be either heteroplasmic or homoplasmic(that is, all copies of the mtDNA carry the mutation), and can affect structural genes or genes encoding the RNA apparatus involved in mitochondrial protein synthesis.3

One particularly intriguing feature of OXPHOS disease is the extreme variability of biochemical and clinical presentations. The basis for this variability remains largely unknown. As far as heteroplasmic mtDNA mutations are concerned, the pathogenicity of a given sequence change can be validated on the basis of rigorous pathogenetic criteria, such as its absolute segregation with the disease, obvious impairment of gene function (for example, frameshift mutations in structural genes), and quantitative correlation of mutation load with clinical and biochemical findings. By contrast, a clear pathogenic role of homoplasmic mutations has been documented in only a few instances, for example, for mutations in the ND genes which give rise to Leber’s hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON), or for the homoplasmic A1555G mutation in the 12S rRNA gene which is associated with aminoglycoside-induced or spontaneous, non-syndromic maternally inherited hearing loss (MIHL).3 The pathogenic significance of these mutations has been persuasively demonstrated, mainly based on a consistent association between maternal lineages carrying a given mutation and the presence of family members affected by specific syndromes (such as LHON or MIHL). However, little is known about the genetic and epigenetic factors determining the remarkably variable penetrance of homoplasmic mutations. Likewise, the reason as to why some mutations only affect a specific tissue whilst other mutations affect several organs, or why a particular mutation can produce widely different clinical symptoms in different individuals, remains poorly understood. This scenario is further complicated by the recent report of two homoplasmic point mutations in mt-tRNA genes. The first mutation, 4300A>G in tRNAIle, has been associated with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy in different kindreds.4 The second, a homoplasmic point mutation in the mtDNA encoded tRNAVal gene, was found in a family consisting of a clinically healthy mother and a child affected by Leigh syndrome.5 The latter was the only surviving child from ten pregnancies with four different partners, the other pregnancies resulting in miscarriage, stillbirth, or death in the neonatal period. In spite of her apparently good health, the mother’s muscle biopsy showed the presence of ragged red fibres and COX depleted fibres, indicating a mitochondrial myopathy. Here we report a similar story, namely a family with a point mutation that was homoplasmic in affected subjects, and largely so in their unaffected mother. The mutation is a novel T>C change in mtDNA tRNAIle, whose pathogenicity has been proven by biochemical and genetic evidence.

Case report

The family pedigree is shown in fig 1.

Figure 1

Pedigree tree. Affected individuals are represented by solid black symbols. Slashed symbols indicate deceased individuals.

The index case (subject II-1) was the third child born to non-consanguineous parents. Pregnancy, birth, and early psychomotor development were normal. The patient was in good health until the age of 16, when she suddenly developed blurred vision, diplopia, headache, vertigo with frequent falls, and generalised weakness and malaise. At the same time she gained more than 10 kg (body mass index = 30 kg/m2) in only a few weeks and was found to be hypertensive with impaired glucose tolerance. The clinical examination disclosed up-beat nystagmus with bilateral gaze evoked horizontal nystagmus and a right VIth nerve palsy. Optokinetic nystagmus was severely disturbed in both directions. General medical and neurological examinations were otherwise normal. Neuropsychological testing revealed no deficits (IQ = 96). The lactate concentration in the cerebrospinal fluid was mildly elevated (2.8 mM, normal values <1.2 mM). Blood lactate and pyruvate were normal both at rest and after an exercise test up to 100 Watts. Abnormal laboratory findings also included impaired glucose tolerance, hyperlipidaemia due to high blood triglycerides, and hyperuricaemia. An electroencephalogram showed mild diffuse slowing (8 Hz) with paroxysms. Electromyography and nerve conduction studies were unremarkable. Brainstem auditory evoked potentials (BAEPs), the blink reflex and motor evoked potentials (MEPs) were normal. Visual evoked potentials revealed bilaterally delayed P100 latencies. Brain magnetic resonance imaging displayed symmetric areas of abnormal signals in the lenticular nuclei, particularly in the caudate nucleus, and also a prominent lesion in the left putamen (fig 2A). In infratentorial sections, the magnetic resonance image displayed symmetric lesions in the mesencephalon, a prominent lesion of the left cerebellar hemisphere and bilateral lesions of the superior cerebellar peduncles (fig 2B). These findings were attributable to focal necrosis and demyelination. Proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy obtained from a single voxel (8 cm3) in the cerebellum showed a pronounced lactate peak at 1.3 ppm (fig 2C). An electrocardiogram and echocardiogram were both unremarkable. Morphological examination of a muscle biopsy taken from the left vastus lateralis failed to reveal significant abnormalities; in particular, no ragged red fibres or cytochrome c oxidase depleted fibres were detected.

Figure 2

Brain magnetic resonance imaging and proton spectroscopy of the index case (II-1). A) A T2 weighted transverse section showing symmetrical lesions of the nucleus caudatus and a left sided lesion of the putamen (arrows). B) A T2 weighted transverse section demonstrates lesions affecting mainly the left cerebellar hemisphere and cerebellar peduncles (arrows). C) Proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy obtained from a single voxel (8 cm3) in the cerebellum shows a pronounced lactate peak (*) at 1.3 ppm.

A younger sister of the index patient, subject II-2, had a similar clinical presentation, but of earlier onset. At the age of 6 years she presented with a syndrome characterised by the sudden onset of double vision, nystagmus and partial VIth nerve palsy. Like her sister, she also developed gross obesity (body mass index = 45 kg/m2) within only a few weeks. The weight gain was associated with hyperlipidaemia and hyperuricaemia. Impaired glucose tolerance was first documented at age 15. In contrast to her sister, patient II-2 was more severely affected and showed developmental delay with impaired cognitive and fine motor skills. Additional neurological symptoms ensued in subsequent years, including mild optic atrophy, moderate dysarthria, marked cerebellar gait, ataxia, and central respiratory disturbances (apnoea, gasping). Despite several low calory diets, she continued to gain weight and finally reached a body mass index of 65 kg/m2. Apart from the metabolic abnormalities mentioned above, the plasma lactate at rest, creatine kinase and other laboratory findings were normal. An electro-encephalogram showed diffuse slow waves; the visual evoked potentials demonstrated significantly delayed P100 latencies, the brainstem auditory evoked potentials suggested a right sided pontomesencephalic lesion. The somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEPs) and motor evoked potentials were both normal. Brain magnetic resonance imaging was similar to that of her elder sister, showing bilateral necrotising encephalomyelopathy, consistent with Leigh syndrome. At the age of 21, the patient died of central respiratory failure. The autopsy confirmed the presence of a subacute necrotising encephalopathy with spongy necrosis, vascular proliferation and gliosis in the cerebellum, basal ganglia and thalamus. There was also bilateral optic neuropathy with round cell infiltrates. The skeletal muscle only showed non-specific changes (that is, increased fibre size variation and a few atrophic fibres). No ragged red fibres or cytochrome c oxidase depleted fibres were detected.

An elder sister of the index patient (subject II-3) died unexpectedly at the age of 1 year, of respiratory arrest after a minor viral infection. Psychomotor development had been normal until then. In the autopsy report, symmetric spongy degeneration of the brainstem was noted, together with marked telangiectatic vascular abnormalities in the mesencephalon.

The mother of both patients, subject I-2, is a 55 year old woman with no neurological symptoms. Clinical examination, neurophysiological testing (BAEP, SSEP, MEP, nerve conduction studies), and magnetic resonance imaging were all normal, as was plasma lactate and creatine kinase. A muscle biopsy failed to show abnormalities.

The karyotypes of individuals I-2, II-1, and II-2 were normal.


Morphological and biochemical analyses

Morphological analysis of skeletal muscle, and biochemical assays of the individual respiratory complexes on muscle homogenate and digitonin-treated fibroblasts were carried out as described.6,7 In fibroblasts and muscle, the specific activities were normalised to that of citrate synthase, an indicator of the number of mitochondria. In cybrids, the specific activities were not normalised, since citrate synthase is present also in mtDNA-less mitochondria which remain in the 143B ρ° cells that we used as “nuclear donors”. These data are therefore presented as nanomoles of reaction product/min/mg of protein. Protein concentration was measured by the method of Lowry.8

Sequence analysis

A total of 11 polymerase chain reaction (PCR) fragments encompassing the entire mtDNA were obtained from genomic DNA using pairs of 25-mer sense and antisense primers, following a standardised protocol.9 Each fragment was directly sequenced in both directions in an ABI 373A automated sequencer (Perkin-Elmer, USA), using the DNA sequencing kit®, and the dye terminator protocol (Perkin-Elmer, USA).

Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis

A 203 base pair fragment encompassing nucleotide positions 4258–4460 of the mtDNA Cambridge sequence2 was PCR amplified using a 34-mer sense oligonucleotide: 5′-ACCTAAGAAATATGTCTGATAAAAGAGGAGCT-3′ (from nucleotide positions 4258–4292) and the following 30-mer antisense oligonucleotide: 5′-AAGGGTATAACCAACATTTTCGGGGTATGG-3′. The underlined GAG triplet replaces a wild-type TTA triplet, to create a diagnostic SaclI restriction site (GAGCTC) specific to the mutant mtDNA species.

After an initial denaturation at 94°C for 1 min, each of the 30 PCR cycles was composed as follows: denaturation at 94°C for 1 min, annealing at 62°C for 40 s, extension at 72°C for 30 s; final extension at 72°C for 5 min. In the presence of the T4290C mutation, the modified sense oligonucleotide creates a SacI-specific restriction site (GAGCTC), which was used for restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis. After digestion with SacI, the cleaved 171 bp and 32 bp fragments, corresponding to the mutant species, were separated from the 203 bp uncut fragment, corresponding to the wild-type species, by non-denaturing polyacrylamide-TBE gel electrophoresis. For last cycle PCR experiments, 0.2 MCi/sample of 32P-dCTP was added in the last PCR cycle. In this set of experiments, after fixation in 10% acetic acid, 25% isopropanol, the TBE gel was washed for 20 minutes in Amplify™ fluorographic reagent (Amersham) and layered onto a phosphor imaging screen (BioRad). After overnight exposure, autoradiography was carried out in a molecular imager apparatus (BioRad). The mutation load was measured by densitometric analysis.

Fibroblast and cybrid cell cultures

Fibroblast cell lines were cultured continuously in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium with 10% FCS.10

Transmitochondrial cybrids were obtained by polyethylene glycol fusion, followed by selection in a uridine-free medium, as described.11 Cytoplasts derived from cytochalasin treated patient’s fibroblasts were fused with a ρ° derivative of the human osteosarcoma 143B.206 cell line. The absence of mtDNA in ρ° cell lines, and its presence in transmitochondrial cybrids was confirmed by PCR using pairs of primers that amplify the D-loop region, as described.12 The presence of the appropriate nuclear genotypes in transmitochondrial cybrids was confirmed by fragment length polymorphism analysis using the highly polymorphic marker D11S533, as described.12

In vivo mtDNA translation

Mitochondrial DNA encoded proteins of semiconfluent cybrid cells, from one clone of patient II-1, were labelled with 35S-methionine (43.5 TBq/mmol) (American Radiolabeled Chemicals) in the presence of emetine (0.2 mg/ml) for 60 min. Proteins were separated by Tricine SDS-PAGE, as described.13 The gel was then fixed for 30 min in 30% methanol, 10% acetic acid, soaked for 60 min in dimethyl sulphoxide, and for 120 min in 22% polyphenylene oxide in dimethyl sulphoxide. After washing in distilled water for 60 min, the gel was dried and exposed for 3–4 days in a screen cassette. The autoradiography was visualised in a bio-imaging analyser (Bas 5000, Fuji Photo Film).

Western blot analysis on two dimension blue native electrophoresis

For two dimension blue native electrophoresis, crude mitochondrial pellets6 were resuspended in 100 µl of 1.5 M 6-aminohexanoic acid, 50 mM Bis-Tris, pH 7.0. Twenty µl of 10% β-lauryl maltoside were added, and the samples were incubated for 15 min on ice. Clearing of the samples was performed by centrifugation at 12000×g for 20 min at 4°C. The supernatant was supplemented with 10 µl of 5% Serva Blue G in 1 M 6-aminohexanoic acid and used for the first dimension. Proteins separated by second dimension blue native PAGE14 were electrotransferred on nylon filters, which were immunostained by using a monoclonal antibody specific to cytochrome c oxidase subunit I, as described.15


Biochemical studies on muscle homogenate and cultured fibroblasts

The clinical picture of the index case pointed to a genetically determined, progressive neurological disorder associated with metabolic disturbances (severe obesity, glucose intolerance, hyperlipidaemia). This suspicion was corroborated by the presence of moderately elevated levels of lactate in the cerebrospinal fluid, and by brain magnetic resonance imaging and proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy findings, both reminiscent of lesions found in Leigh syndrome (fig 2). Therefore, we performed skin biopsies in the index case (II-1), in the affected sister (II-2) and in the apparently healthy mother (I-2). As reported in table 1, in all samples, including that of the mother, we found defects of mtDNA-related respiratory chain complexes, in particular complexes I and IV. By contrast, the activity of complex II, a nuclear encoded complex, was normal. Likewise, no biochemical abnormality was detected in the muscle homogenate of two muscle biopsies, one taken from the index patient, the other from her mother (not shown).

Table 1

Enzymatic activities in fibroblasts

Biochemical studies on cybrids

To establish whether the gene mutation underlying the disease was carried by a nuclear or mitochondrial gene, we performed a complementation assay on transmitochondrial cybrids. The latter were produced by fusing cytoplasts derived from fibroblasts of the two affected sisters and their mother, with mtDNA-less (ρ°) 143B.206 human osteosarcoma cells. We collected a total of 13 cybrid clones from the three different fibroblast cell lines. All clones were proven to contain 100% mutant mtDNA (see below). Biochemical analysis (table 2) demonstrated that the defects of complex I and complex IV which were found in fibroblasts were also present in all of the cybrids, which contained the mtDNA of the probands as their only genetic contribution. The amount and integrity of cybrid mtDNA was proven by Southern blot15 and real time PCR analysis16 (not shown). These studies excluded a significant reduction in the mtDNA copy number of the cybrid clones. Suitable markers were used to prove that no nuclear DNA belonging to the probands was present in the cybrid derivatives (not shown). These results clearly indicated that a deleterious mutation in the probands’ mtDNA was responsible of the biochemical defects in the respiratory chain and, as a consequence, of the clinical picture in the affected individuals.

Table 2

Enzymatic activities in cybrids

Sequence analysis of mtDNA

Sequence analysis of the entire mtDNA molecule of the index patient (subject II-1) revealed the presence of a mutation replacing a wild-type T at nucleotide position 4290 with a C (fig 3A), in the anticodon loop of the tRNAIle cloverleaf structure (fig 3B). Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of an allele specific PCR fragment using the diagnostic restriction endonuclease SacI confirmed the results obtained by nucleotide sequence analysis (fig 3C). RFLP analysis of last cycle radioactive PCR showed that the mutation was homoplasmic in mtDNA from skeletal muscle, fibroblasts and lymphocytes. The same homoplasmic mutation was detected in mtDNA extracted from lymphocytes and fibroblasts of the affected sister and in fibroblasts and skeletal muscle of the mother. Overexposure of the blot revealed a faint band corresponding to wild-type mtDNA in the mother’s lymphocyte sample. We estimated this wild-type mt DNA as being approximately 3% of the total amount of mtDNA. The mutation was absent in 500 mtDNA control samples. As shown in fig 3D, the mutant C is conserved throughout eukaryotic species, including most of the metazoans, several plants, and fungi. In addition, this change can in principle produce an abnormal pairing with an opposite G (fig 3B), creating a distortion in the structure of the anticodon loop, which may interfere with the binding of the tRNA to the corresponding Ile codons. In addition to the 4290T>C change, we found sixteen homoplasmic polymorphisms of mtDNA that were already reported as non-pathogenic changes in the MITOMAP database (see for details). We also found a previously unreported homoplasmic 8818C>T polymorphism corresponding to a synonymous change from codon CTA to codon TTA, both specific to Leu98 of ATPase6. Two additional, previously unreported changes were found in the 12S rRNA gene (745A>G) and in the 16S rRNA gene (3204C>T), respectively. These positions are not conserved in mammalian species (see for details). The same changes were found in subjects II-2 and I-2.

Figure 3

Identification and analysis of the 4290T>C mutation in mtDNA-tRNAIle (A) Automated sequence analysis of the region encompassing the 4290T>C mutation (asterisk) of the probands’ mtDNA. Peaks corresponding to each nucleotide are indicated by different colours. (B) Proposed secondary structures of the tRNAIle gene transcript. The mutant C replaces the wild-type U (arrow) in the tRNA anticodon loop. The wild-type and mutant nucleotides are in magenta. The GAU anticodon sequence is in red. (C) Below the symbols of each individual are the results of last cycle radioactive PCR and Sac I RFLP analysis on lymphocyte (L), fibroblast (F) and skeletal muscle (M) DNA samples of family members available for the study. The blot was overexposed to visualise a faint band corresponding to wild-type mtDNA in the lymphocyte DNA sample from individual I-2. (D) Interspecific conservation of the tRNAIle anticodon loop. The T at position 4290 in the wt mtDNA of Homo sapiens (in magenta) is conserved in all the organisms considered in the analysis.

In vivo translation studies

To evaluate the consequence of the mutation on mtDNA translation, an in vivo assay was performed on a mutant cybrid clone from the index case, and control (143B.206) cells. As shown in fig 4, the mtDNA-specific translation pattern obtained from the mutant cell line was similar to that of the control cell line. However, the band set corresponding to subunits ND5, COI, and ND4 of mtDNA were clearly reduced in the mutant cybrid clone compared to the control cell line. This result was confirmed by comparing the densitometric profiles of the autoradiographs (fig 4).

Figure 4

In vitro translation of mtDNA encoded polypeptides in 143B.206 cells and a mutant cybrid clone from patient II-1. Left panel: autoradiograph of one dimension SDS-PAGE. ND, subunits of Complex I; cyt b, cytochrome b (Complex III); CO, subunits of Complex IV; ATP, subunits of Complex V; WT, wild-type. Right panel: densitometric profiles of 143B.206 cells (magenta line) and mutant cybrid clone (black line).

Studies on cytochrome c oxidase assembly

To understand the consequences of the mutation on the assembly of the mtDNA-dependent respiratory chain complexes, and in particular of complex IV (cytochrome c oxidase), western blot analysis using an antibody specific to cytochrome c oxidase subunit I was carried out on equal amounts of mitochondrial proteins, extracted from the same number of mutant cybrids and 143B.206 cells, and separated by two dimension blue native electrophoresis. Four subcomplexes (S1, S2, S3, and S4) have previously been defined by two dimension blue native electrophoresis as cytochrome c oxidase assembly intermediates of increasing molecular weight.15,17–19 In normal conditions, S1 corresponds to the incorporation of cytochrome c oxidase subunit I. This first step is followed by the incorporation of cytochrome c oxidase subunit IV, producing a second intermediate, S2. The third intermediate, S3, is the result of the incorporation in the nascent complex formed by cytochrome c oxidase I and IV of a large series of subunits, including cytochrome c oxidase subunits II, III, Va, Vb, Vc, VIb, VIc, VIIb, VIIc, and VIII. Finally, fully assembled cytochrome c oxidase, corresponding to S4, is completed by the incorporation of two late subunits, cytochrome c oxidase VIa and VIIa. As shown in fig 5, in 143B.206 control cells, most of the cross reacting material specific to cytochrome c oxidase I was confined to S4, corresponding to fully assembled cytochrome c oxidase. By contrast, most of the cross reacting material in two mutant cybrid clones (from subjects II-1 and I-2) were present in intermediate subcomplexes S1-S2-S3. The fully assembled complex, S4, was reduced. The densitometrically estimated amount of assembled cytochrome c oxidase was approximately 50% in the mutants, relative to the control cell line homogenates, a percentage similar to that of the corresponding specific activities (see tables 1 and 2).

Figure 5

Western blot analysis of cytochrome c oxidase subunit I from two dimension blue native electrophoresis performed on crude mitochondrial extracts. The upper and middle panels show the results on cybrid clones from probands I-2 and II-1; the bottom panel shows the results on 143B.206 cells taken as a control. Arrows indicate the directions of the 1st and 2nd electrophoretic run. S1–3 indicate cytochrome c oxidase assembly intermediates of increasing molecular mass. S4 corresponds to fully assembled cytochrome c oxidase.


We found a homoplasmic mutation in the mtDNA tRNAIle gene in a mitochondrial disease affecting two sisters. A third sibling, reported as having similar clinical presentation, died several years ago and could not be investigated. Surprisingly, the mutation was also present as a homoplasmic or nearly homoplasmic change in the unaffected mother, who displayed the same OXPHOS defects in both fibroblasts and cybrids as those found in the same cells from the two affected daughters.

The hypothesis that the tRNAlle mutation is pathogenic in this family is supported by the following evidence. Firstly, the tRNAlle change was the only mutation affecting a highly conserved position in the entire mtDNA sequence of the probands. Other mtDNA changes were known polymorphisms or synonymous changes that do not alter the predicted sequences of the corresponding proteins. Two additional changes affect non-conserved regions in the rRNA genes. Secondly, the mutation can alter the secondary, and possibly tertiary, structure of the anticodon tRNA loop. Thirdly, the mutation was absent in more than 500 mtDNAs from European subjects taken as controls. Fourthly, and more importantly, the biochemical phenotype identified in fibroblast cell lines of the probands, consisting in severe, multiple defects of mtDNA-related respiratory chain complexes, was retained in all the numerous cybrid clones generated from different mutant fibroblast cell lines. This result indicates that, irrespective of the nuclear background, the OXPHOS defect segregated as a mtDNA trait in this family. Fifthly, transmission of the defect was compatible with a maternally inherited trait, since all the offspring of a mutant mother were affected. Finally, lower steady state levels of translation products corresponding to the largest mtDNA-encoded respiratory subunits were found in a cybrid clone from the index patient. This result is coherent with the hypothesis of a functional defect in a mtDNA-encoded tRNA.

The tRNAIle mutation was homoplasmic in all the available tissues of both affected siblings and in muscle and fibroblasts of their healthy mother. With the exception of a very low percentage of wild-type mtDNA detected by an ultrasensitive radioactive PCR assay in the mother’s lymphocyte mtDNA, this condition is similar to that reported in most of the mtDNA mutations associated with LHON20 and MIHL.21,22 In addition, both affected members and maternal relatives from two families with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy carried the same 4300A>G homoplasmic mutation in tRNAIle,4 and a family composed of an apparently healthy mother, a child affected by severe Leigh-like syndrome and several stillbirths or miscarriages was recently reported to carry a homoplasmic mutation in the tRNAVal gene in different tissues.4 The offspring of this family, consisting of 10 conceptions altogether, were generated by the same mother with four different partners, clearly indicating maternal inheritance of the disease trait. The mother of this family was indeed affected by a subclinical mitochondrial myopathy. However, no biochemical phenotype was detected in fibroblast cell lines or cybrids. In our case, an OXPHOS phenotype was clearly present in fibroblasts and cybrid cell lines from both mother and daughters. This result conclusively identifies mtDNA as the genome responsible for the neurological syndrome affecting the two sisters, and possibly a third one deceased long ago. By contrast, the skeletal muscle was morphologically and biochemically spared in one of the two sisters and in the mother. We do not have experimental based evidence to explain this observation, which was indeed a surprising finding since mitochondrial myopathy is common in OXPHOS disease. However, a number of mtDNA mutations have been reported to be associated with tissue specific abnormalities, in which involvement of skeletal muscle was absent. The most obvious example is provided by the LHON mutations, but also by the 8993T>G mutation causing NARP, or by the several mtDNA mutations associated with maternally inherited deafness. The condition that is perhaps the most similar to ours is the 4300A>G mutation in tRNAIle. This mutation, which was found as a homoplasmic change in families with maternally inherited isolated cardiomyopathy of variable penetrance, was shown to be associated with very low steady state levels of the tRNAIle transcript in heart, but not in skeletal muscle. Accordingly, a severe, combined defect of complex I and IV was detected in the heart muscle, but not in the skeletal muscle of an index case.4 These observations, including that reported in the present paper, support the concept that the phenotypes of homoplasmic mtDNA mutations are strongly influenced by still unknown, possibly multiple, factors, that not only dictate the disease penetrance in different individuals, but also the biochemical and clinical consequences in different tissues and, possibly, in different stages of development.23

Interestingly enough, the two affected sisters showed a very similar natural history of the disease. Although the younger sister (subject II-2) was more severely affected than the elder (subject I-1, index case), both developed very similar lesions, as seen by magnetic resonance imaging, and the neurological signs and symptoms were virtually identical. Both developed the same “metabolic abnormalities”, including gross obesity, glucose intolerance and hyperlipidaemia.

As frequently seen in mitochondrial encephalopathy, our patients were affected by a progressive, multisystem failure of neurological functions, particularly those localised in the brainstem and deep brain nuclei. The clinical presentation was congruent with the presence of lesions documented by magnetic resonance imaging distributed throughout the deep grey structures of the brain, similar to those found in Leigh syndrome,24,25 an early onset neurological entity attributed to several biochemical defects in the mitochondrial energy pathway.26,27 Elevated levels of lactate in the cerebrospinal fluid, an index of impaired aerobic metabolism, was accompanied by the identification of lactate accumulation in the brain lesions of the index case, as revealed by proton magnetic resonance spectrometry. In contrast with typical Leigh syndrome, however, the onset of the disease was delayed and its course was slowly progressive in our patients. The neurological picture was dominated by ataxia, dysarthria, and other cerebellar signs, by bilateral involvement of the optic nerve, and by several symptoms attributable to lesions of specific structures in the brainstem and mesencephalon. The lesions found by both magnetic resonance imaging and neuropathological examination were partly symmetrical, as typically seen in Leigh syndrome.25 However, some asymmetrical lesions were also found, such as the prominent involvement of the right cerebellar hemisphere of the index patient shown in fig 3C. The “metabolic” features, such as hyperlipidaemia and glucose intolerance, can also be attributed to the primary mitochondrial abnormality,28 or could be ascribed to the severe obesity affecting both patients. The nature and pathogenesis of the obesity is presently poorly understood. Delayed or impaired body growth, rather than weight gain, is a common feature in mitochondrial disease.29 Reduced utilisation of nutrients, endocrine abnormalities that can further decrease energy production (for example, hypothyroidism)29 and compulsory hyperphagia due to disturbances of the central nervous system, could in principle produce an increase of fatty mass and gross obesity. No hypothyroidism or compulsory hyperphagia were reported in our patients. This aspect of the syndrome requires further investigation.

The most striking feature of our tRNAlle mutant family was the absence of clinical and neuroradiological signs in the mother of the two probands, in spite of her showing the same biochemical defects of the patients, and being a carrier of the same mutation, that was homoplasmic in two cell types and nearly homoplasmic in a third. Another intriguing feature of our patients was the virtual absence of clinical, morphological, and biochemical abnormalities in the skeletal muscle of the probands, since myopathy is a common feature of mitochondrial disorders.30 Both these findings illustrate the variability in penetrance and expressivity of disease associated with homoplasmic mtDNA mutations. Compensatory effects provided by epigenetic (environmental) factors or, more likely, by different nuclear genetic backgrounds, may offer an explanation for this intriguing phenomenon. For instance, overexpression of genes such as the Et-UF elongation factor has been proven to compensate the translational defect and the consequent biochemical deficiency of specific mtDNA-tRNA mutations in yeast cells.31 The study of the differential expression profiles in affected and non-affected individuals carrying the same homoplasmic mutation of mtDNA is a promising, but yet to be set up approach to address this difficult question. We predict that homoplasmic pathogenic mutations in the mitochondrial genome represent a potentially vast, still largely overlooked and poorly understood area of mitochondrial medicine, and will stand as a new challenge in the nosological and physiopathological definition of these disorders in the next future.


We are indebted to Ms B Geehan for revising the manuscript.


View Abstract


  • * These authors contributed equally to this work.

  • Supported by Fondazione Telethon-Italy (grant GGP030039 to MZ), Fondazione Pierfranco e Luisa Mariani (Ricerca 2000 to MZ), Ricerca Finalizzata Ministero della Salute RF-2002/158 (to MZ), Fondazione Cariplo (to MZ), MitEuro network grant from the European Union Framework Program 5 (to MZ), DFG-Scha 551/2–1 (to JS), and InnoRegio BioMet (to SJ).

  • Conflicts of interest: none declared.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.