Article Text

PDF

Cleft lip and palate. From origin to treatment
  1. J Murray

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    Edited by Diego Wyszynski. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002, £110, pp 518. ISBN 0195139062

    This compendium of 42 chapters purports to provide graduate students, practitioners, researchers, parents, and siblings with information that can facilitate efforts to reduce rates of cleft lip and palate and to increase the quality and years of healthy life of individuals who are born with these conditions. It succeeds admirably. It is difficult to put together such a comprehensive volume that covers issues from very basic embryology and genetics through to family based resources and support groups. Dr Wyszynski has assembled an impressive collection of experts in the field and has succeeded in providing individual chapters that are comprehensive and up to date in their coverage and reasonably well integrated as well. Although some subjects are covered in more depth than others, there appear to be no major omissions from the overall effort and in several cases chapters are the best summaries as well as the most detailed overviews on the topic that have yet been written. Many individual chapters will be able to serve as reference points for years to come. Several chapters have been particularly effective in providing detailed bibliographies as well as summary tables.

    In any summary this large, one could certainly find weaknesses to nitpick. Some chapters overlap and fail to be integrated. Others do not provide the depth of information or background that one might desire, and the glossary and index are relatively short for the amount of information contained in the volume as a whole and appear to overemphasise genetic and embryologic findings and underemphasise clinical and patient care aspects. Some individual hot topics such as distraction osteogenesis were difficult to find mention of at all, while others were covered repeatedly in several chapters, sometimes with conflicting interpretations.

    These minor criticisms aside, the volume has much to recommend it. Numerous tables provide comprehensive summaries of epidemiological, genetic, embryological, surgical approaches, and incidence/prevalence data. It is well illustrated with embryological and surgical views and interpretations and provides a number of in depth discussions of controversial points including clinical trials in surgery, recurrence prevention strategies, and epidemiological approaches. Some particular strengths also include an emphasis on patient and family based care as well as the availability of resources for researchers, clinicians, and family members.

    Although some of the text is inevitably focused on an individual’s particular expertise or background, there is overall a strong and successful attempt to integrate international experts with international questions and approaches. Given a disorder such as cleft lip and palate that has such variable distribution around the world and where the availability of care is remarkably inconsistent, this edited text has been very successful in raising important questions that are currently relevant in highly developed countries, including those both with and without national health care systems, as well as in issues that are of compelling importance for less developed countries where the availability of even single contact reconstructive surgery may be difficult for much of the affected population.

    I particularly enjoyed reading the clinical and patient care oriented summaries and found much of the tabular summaries very useful and very well done. Because the text is so broad in its task and has been so competently done, it should serve as an invaluable resource for anyone working with cleft lip and palate, whether they be researchers or clinicians. It is a text that truly belongs as a standard reference in not only every clinic that takes care of such patients, but also on the desks of epidemiologists, embryologists, geneticists, nutritionists, speech pathologists, dentists, psychologists, and others who care for such children. It seems likely that this will serve as a classic text for many years to come and one hopes that in the future newly edited and updated versions will become available as well.

    View Abstract

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.