Article Text

A heterozygous endothelin 3 mutation in Waardenburg-Hirschsprung disease: is there a dosage effect ofEDN3/EDNRB gene mutations on neurocristopathy phenotypes?

Statistics from

Editor—Hirschsprung disease and Waardenburg syndrome are congenital malformations involving neural crest derivatives. Several genes are involved in these diseases, defining a complex pattern of inheritance. Hirschsprung disease (HSCR) is characterised by the absence of intramural ganglia in the distal bowel. This lack of enteric innervation results in intestinal obstruction or severe constipation. The incidence of HSCR is 1 per 5000 live births and both genetic and environmental factors are thought to contribute to the phenotype. The mode of inheritance is dominant in some families and recessive or multifactorial in others.1 In a number of cases, mutations of the RET proto-oncogene, a tyrosine kinase receptor, result in a dominant disease with incomplete penetrance.2-4 Mutations in theRET ligand GDNF(glial cell line derived neurotrophic factor) may also affect the phenotype.5-7 A few patients with HSCR were found to have heterozygous mutations in the genes encoding the endothelin B receptor (EDNRB)8-10 or its ligand endothelin 3 (EDN3).11 12

Waardenburg syndrome (WS) is characterised by a combination of sensorineural deafness and abnormal pigmentation, including a white forelock and eyelashes, heterochromia irides, and areas of skin depigmentation. Four subtypes of WS have been described on the basis of clinical features.13 Types 1 and 3 and type 2 are associated with mutations in the PAX3 and microphthalmia associated transcription factor (MITF) genes,14 respectively. Patients with type 4 WS (WS4, Waardenburg-Hirschsprung disease or Shah-Waardenburg syndrome) have features of both WS and HSCR.15 Several WS4 subjects have homozygousEDNRB or EDN3gene mutations,12 16-19 whereas other patients have heterozygous mutations in the gene encoding SOX10,20 a transcription factor expressed in emerging neural crest cells.

Endothelins are a family of three vasoactive peptides recognised by two G protein coupled heptahelical receptors. Endothelin 3 preferentially binds the endothelin B receptor. Endothelin mRNAs are first translated into preproendothelin, which undergoes two step enzymatic cleavage that generates the active endothelin peptide21 22 (fig 1). This peptide is composed of 21 amino acids, and contains four cysteines involved in two disulphide bonds. Targeted or spontaneous homozygous mutations of the Ednrb orEdn3 gene in mice generate a strikingly similar phenotype, with white coat spotting and aganglionic megacolon,24 25 suggesting that endothelin 3 is a physiological ligand for the endothelin B receptor. The phenotype is reminiscent of WS4 in humans, in whom homozygous mutations ofEDNRB and EDN3were first described.16-19 Heterozygous mutations were later reported in patients with isolated HSCR.8-12Following these observations, WS4 was described as a recessive condition, and isolated HSCR as a dominant disease with incomplete penetrance when the result of EDN3 orEDNRB mutations.

Figure 1

Enzymatic processing of preproendothelin into proendothelin (also termed “big endothelin”) and into mature endothelin, according to Yanagisawa et al.23

However, contrary to this simple model, a homozygousEDNRB mutation was found in a patient with isolated HSCR26 and a heterozygous mutation was identified in a patient with WS4, whose affected sibs only had features of WS.27 EDNRB mutations manifest themselves in a more complex manner than previously believed. In their study of a large Mennonite family, Puffenberger et al 16 showed that both homozygotes and heterozygotes for a EDNRB mutation exhibited the intestinal phenotype, but with very different penetrance (21% in heterozygotes, 74% in homozygotes). They suggested that theEDNRB mutation found in this family was dosage sensitive and neither fully dominant nor fully recessive. This explanation for the variable penetrance in homozygotes and heterozygotes might also apply to features of WS. However, it would not predict whether a particular EDNRB mutation would be more strongly associated with HSCR or with WS, as modifier genes could also contribute to determining whether a heterozygote develops one syndrome or the other.

Similarly, heterozygous EDN3 mutations have been identified in patients with HSCR and homozygousEDN3 mutations in patients with WS4.12 28 We report a novelEDN3 mutation carried in the heterozygous state by a girl with WS4, showing that, likeEDNRB, heterozygousEDN3 mutations can result in either WS4 or isolated HSCR.

The index case (III.2) was born in a well nourished state after a pregnancy marked by sonographic diagnosis of an intestinal obstruction at 33 weeks. The karyotype was normal (46,XX). Laparotomy on day 3 of life established the diagnosis of HSCR involving the colon and ileum. Multiple biopsy specimens of the distal ileum and colon showed no ganglion cells in the submucosa or intermuscular nerve plexuses and no increase in nerve fibres. An ileostomy in the dilated ileum failed to function and jejunostomy was carried out on day 15, 40 cm from the duodenum. The child required almost total parenteral nutrition. During the neonatal period the baby had a white forelock, which gradually disappeared over a period of months. Mild sensorineural hearing loss was diagnosed when she was 4 months old. Chronic intestinal infection with cholangitis and liver dysfunction occurred, together with several episodes of septicaemia requiring antibiotics (including aminoglycosides). Physical examination at 1 year of age showed areas of hypopigmentation on the hands, and an electrophysiological hearing test showed severe, bilateral, sensorineural hearing loss. Heterochromia of the irises and dystopia canthorum were absent. The child failed to thrive and liver failure necessitated liver and intestinal transplantation at the age of 5 years. She died six weeks later of septic shock.

Pregnancy III.3 (fig 2) was terminated at 29 weeks, in accordance with French law, after an intestinal obstruction was identified sonographically. Necropsy showed the same pattern of HSCR affecting the ileum and colon. There were no other discernible morphogenic defects. The mother (II.4) and father (II.5) are non-consanguineous. I.1, I.2, II.4, and III.1 (9 years old) are healthy. Their physical examination showed no malformations or dysmorphism. Their audiograms were normal. I.1 and I.2 are of Yugoslavian origin. II.2 was born at term in a well nourished state, but died in Yugoslavia in the neonatal period from congenital intestinal obstruction (no medical records are available). The father (II.5) and his family (of French origin) had no relevant history.

Figure 2

(A) Pedigree of the family. Subjects for whom a DNA sample was available are represented, along with the results of EDN3 genotyping. II.2 is thought to have been affected, as he died from neonatal intestinal obstruction, but no medical records are available. An intestinal obstruction was detected prenatally in the male fetus III.3 and the pregnancy was terminated. (B) The C169X mutation. Results of direct sequencing of EDN3 exon 3 from genomic DNA of a control (above) and the index case III2 (below); consequences of the mutation for preproendothelin 3 structure. The mature endothelin 3 peptide (ET3) is in grey and the ET-like peptide is striped.

The coding sequences of the three genes involved in WS4 (EDN3, EDNRB, andSOX10) were screened by means of single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis in the index case, as previously described12 20 (the sequences of theEDNRB primers were kindly provided by J Amiel). A band shift was observed in a fragment corresponding to exon 3 of the EDN3 gene. Sequencing of the variant fragment showed a heterozygous C→A transition, which introduces a stop codon at position 169 (fig 2B). This mutation, C169X, was inherited from the healthy mother (fig 2A) and was not found in 100 control chromosomes. As WS4 is classically considered to result from homozygous EDN3 mutations, we investigated this family further.

The coding sequence of the RETproto-oncogene was screened for mutations on III.3 fetal DNA by SSCP analysis (exons 1 and 2) and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) (all other exons) as previously described.29 No causative substitutions or neutral variants were detected. Haplotypes inherited at the RET locus were reconstructed by genotyping the parents' DNA for six known intragenic polymorphisms in exons 2, 7, 11, 13, 14, and 15.30 31 A single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) of intron 19 and a microsatellite marker located 80 kb upstream of the RETgene (MS, unpublished results) were also analysed. The presence of an interstitial microdeletion was ruled out in the most proximal portion, but loss of heterozygosity (LOH) analysis was not fully informative for the rest of the gene.

Other mutations in the EDN3,EDNRB, and SOX10genes were sought by directly sequencing genomic DNA extracted from the girl's blood cells (III.2) and from a lymphoblastoid cell line established from III.3 fetal cells. No other mutation was found. The absence of partial deletion or rearrangement of theEDN3 gene was shown by Southern blotting. The girl's (III.2) and control DNA was digested withBamHI or BclI, and human EDN3 cDNA32 was used as a probe (ATCC). Finally, to detect possible extinction of the normalEDN3 allele in the girl, we amplified exon 3 and the junction with exon 4 by reverse transcription from the lymphoblastoid cell line RNA and nested PCR using the following conditions: 20 pmol of each primer, 1.5 mmol/l Mg, annealing temperature 55°C, 35 cycles. First round PCR primers: F 5′CGAACAGACGGTGCCCTATGGAC3′, R 5′ATGAGCTTTGGATGGTGGAGGTC3′. Nested primers: F 5′GACTGTCCAACTACAGAGGAAGC3′, R 5′CCTGCTTGCTTT GTTGGTCCTTG3′. The PCR products were analysed on 2% agarose gel before sequencing. Several amplification products corresponding to some of the previously described alternatively spliced mRNAs were observed.32 33The normal and mutated EDN3 alleles could be amplified from both the mother and the girl (not shown).

The C169X mutation of the EDN3 gene lies in a region of the distal preproendothelin called the ET-like peptide (fig2B). This 15 amino acid peptide shows a very high degree of homology with the mature endothelin peptide, and also with the three preproendothelins from various species. In particular, the four cysteines are conserved. The ET-like peptide might play a role in the first enzymatic cleavage step. The absence of this first cleavage step impairs the final clipping step by endothelin conversion enzyme (ECE-1).34 As a result, the C169X mutation, by substituting the third cysteine of the ET-like peptide, prevents the disulphide bonds and probably generates an inappropriately cleaved, inactive proendothelin. It is noteworthy that another of the threeEDN3 mutations described to date in WS4 disrupts the disulphide bonds of the ET-like peptide. This defect, C159F, described in the homozygous state,18 modifies the first cysteine. A functional in vitro assay has been used to show that this mutation results in a virtual absence of the mature endothelin 3 product, supporting the hypothesis of impaired cleavage (Yanagisawa, cited in Hofstra et al 28).

To date, three heterozygous EDN3 gene mutations have been described in isolated HSCR, and three homozygous mutations have been observed in WS4. Interestingly, in one of the WS4 families, certain members who are heterozygous for theEDN3 gene C159F mutation have one or more WS features but are free of megacolon.18 This is incompatible with a recessive mode of WS inheritance and with a dominant mode of HSCR transmission. Another patient, with a congenital central hypoventilation syndrome (CCHS) but free of HSCR and pigmentation defects, carries a heterozygous EDN3frameshift mutation involving the carboxy-terminal region of the prepropeptide.35 However, a functional in vitro test failed to show any effect of this mutation on preproendothelin processing, raising questions as to the deleterious nature of the mutation.

The aborted fetus III.3, which was heterozygous, also had severe intestinal disease, but the presence of WS features could not be assessed. The maternal grandfather and a healthy brother were also heterozygous. It is likely that a maternal uncle, who died at birth from intestinal obstruction, also carried the mutation. As in most other cases described, penetrance was incomplete. Two of the three heterozygous EDN3 mutations so far identified in isolated HSCR were inherited from an asymptomatic mother,12 while one was inherited from a mother with a mild intestinal phenotype.11 Incomplete penetrance and phenotypic variability are frequent in neurocristopathies, particularly in HSCR. This could be explained by environmental factors, multigenic inheritance (see for example Bolk et al 36), or modifier genes, or by stochastic events acting on cell fate or cell differentiation in early embryogenesis. The EDN3/EDNRB ligand/receptor interaction is essential for the development of two different cell lineages, melanocytes and enteric neurones, derived from the neural crest. It is unclear whether this interaction is required by early progenitors of both lineages or only after the lineages diverge. Differences in the chronological order and sites of emergence of distinct subsets of cells derived from the neural crest could partly account for the variable manifestations associated withEDN3 and EDNRBmutations.

This characterisation of the EDN3 C169X mutation shows that features of both WS and HSCR can result from a heterozygous EDN3 mutation. One possible explanation for this observation includes multigenic inheritance. Indeed, involvement of an unidentified gene cannot be ruled out in this family. A mutation of the endothelin conversion enzyme gene (ECE1) has been described in a patient with a very particular phenotype, including cardiac defects, craniofacial abnormalities, other dysmorphic features, and autonomic dysfunction,37 which were not found in the family investigated here. Another possibility in keeping with our findings is a mode of inheritance which is not fully recessive and not fully dominant, with different penetrance in homozygotes and heterozygotes, as suggested for EDNRB mutations. Alternatively, the ET-like peptide mutations could have a particular mode of transmission and phenotypic expression.

This description of a heterozygous EDN3mutation in a severe case of Waardenburg-Hirschsprung disease underlines the difficulty in predicting the phenotypic manifestations of EDN3 mutations. This situation complicates genetic counselling and requires care when assessing the recurrence risk in a family.


This work was supported by Biomed (contract BMH4-CT97-2107) and the Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM).


View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.