Statistics from Altmetric.com
Editor—A g.133283G>A (nomenclature in accordance with Rowen et al 1) single base change in exon 3 of the cationic trypsinogen gene or T4, resulting in an Arg (CGC) to His (CAC) substitution at amino acid residue 122 (R122H, originally named R117H in the chymotrypsin numbering system; nomenclature discussed in detail in Chen and Ferec2) of the cationic pretrypsinogen, was shown to be associated with hereditary pancreatitis (HP, MIM 167800) in 1996.3 To date, this mutation has been shown to be the most frequent mutation in HP world wide.4-9 The occurrence of g.133283G>A could be attributable to a spontaneous deamination of 5-methylcytosine to give thymine in the CpG dinucleotides on the opposite strand.
In an effort to screen for possible cationic trypsinogen gene mutations in sporadic chronic pancreatitis, which was diagnosed on clinical features and pathological sonographic findings, we observed one altered migration pattern different from that of the g.133283G>A transition in exon 3 of the gene from one Belgian patient using a previously established denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis.8Subsequent sequencing analysis showed a novel DNA variant named g.133283∼133284GC>AT, which also resulted in an R122H mutation of the protein (fig 1). However, in contrast to the CGC>CAC codon change, CGC>CAT strongly suggests an alternative mutational mechanism, gene conversion.
Gene conversion, the non-reciprocal exchange of genetic information between homologous DNA sequences, has been extensively studied in lower eukaryotes. This mechanism has also been increasingly implicated in human diseases, in which the disease causing mutations identified in the functional genes were believed to be copied from their closely related pseudogenes.10-12 In this study, the GC>AT 2 bp mutation in T4 arising as a gene conversion event was supported by the presence of AT at corresponding positions of T6 and T7 among the closely related group I trypsinogen genes (fig 2).13Furthermore, a Chi-like sequence (5′-GCTGGAGG-3′, complementary strand), which has one mismatch with the consensus Chi sequence (5′-GCTGGTGG-3′) was found to be located 27 nucleotides downstream from the mutation.Chi-like sequences have been reported to stimulate recombination and are frequently observed in the proximity of putatively converted alleles.10 14 However, like other gene conversion events, it is difficult to establish the exact boundaries of the conversion tract in our example, which is further complicated by the presence of two possible donor sequences. Nevertheless, we prefer the T7 gene to be the culprit and accordingly this “patchy” microconversion event would involve the exchange of up to 30 nucleotides between the T4 and T7 genes.
The identification of a germline R122H mutation in a sporadic case may represent a de novo mutation in one of the parental alleles, which could be investigated by analysing genomic DNA samples from the non-symptomatic parents. Unfortunately, this was not done owing to the inability to obtain such DNA samples. However, the identification of a clearly pancreatitis causing, germline R122H mutation definitely represents a high risk factor for the carrier's offspring.
This genetic finding also raises practical concerns. Since the g.133283G>A single nucleotide change creates a novel restriction enzyme recognition site for Alf III (A▾CRYGT), the specific amplification of exon 3 followed byAlf III digestion3 has been widely adopted to detect the R122H mutation both in hereditary4-6 9 and sporadic9 15 cases of pancreatitis. Clearly, this simple method is unable to detect the g.133283∼133284GC>AT 2 bp mutation. Thus, the possibility of a gene conversion event should be considered for the genotyping of pancreatitis, particularly when the known mutations are not detectable and linkage to the trypsinogen gene locus cannot be excluded in certain HP families.
We thank Isabelle Quere for help with sequencing. This work was supported by the INSERM (CRI 96-07). JMC is a postdoctoral scientist and has received a grant from the INSERM.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.