Article Text


Recessively inherited multiple epiphyseal dysplasia with normal stature, club foot, and double layered patella caused by a DTDST mutation


We have observed over 25 different mutations in the diastrophic dysplasia sulphate transporter gene (DTDST) in association with the recessive disorders achondrogenesis 1B, atelosteogenesis 2, and diastrophic dysplasia. The c862t (R279W) transition is the most common mutation in non-Finnish patients, but in these disorders it is usually combined with otherDTDST mutations. We had not seen a case of homozygosity for c862t (R279W) until we analysed DNA from a 36 year old male with tall-normal stature (180 cm) who asked for genetic counselling for suspected multiple epiphyseal dysplasia. He was treated for club foot and hip dysplasia at birth. Skeletal changes consistent with multiple epiphyseal dysplasia, with the peculiar finding of a double layered patella, were recognised during childhood. Cleft palate, swelling of the ear pinna, and hitch hiker thumb were absent. He was found to be homozygous, and both healthy parents heterozygous, for the R279W mutation in DTDST, and his fibroblasts showed a sulphate incorporation defect typical of DTDST disorders. Counselling was given for a recessive disorder, thereby considerably reducing the probability of affected offspring.

 Multiple epiphyseal dysplasia is more frequently caused by dominant mutations in the COMP (EDM1, McKusick 132400) and COL9A2 genes (EDM2, McKusick 600204). A few other patients and families with features similar to our proband have been described previously and considered to have autosomal recessive MED (EDM4, McKusick 226900). This observation confirms the existence of this entity and assigns it to the phenotypic spectrum associated with mutations at theDTDST locus.

  • multiple epiphyseal dysplasia
  • double layered patella

Statistics from

Recessive mutations in the diastrophic dysplasia sulphate transporter gene (DTDST) are the cause of a continuous spectrum of bone dysplasia which includes, as “landmark” phenotypes, achondrogenesis 1B, atelosteogenesis 2, and diastrophic dysplasia.1-4 In the course of molecular characterisation of patients and their families for confirmation of diagnosis, genetic counselling, and prenatal diagnosis, we have observed over 25 differentDTDST mutations.1 2 5-8Among these mutations, c862t (R279W) is the single most common in non-Finnish patients, accounting for approximately a quarter of disease alleles. Its presence in patients from different ethnic backgrounds and its occurrence at a CpG dinucleotide is consistent with independent mutation events. In spite of its original observation in a patient with AO2,6 this mutation is mostly associated with a non-lethal phenotype. In fact, in spite of its relative frequency, we have so far observed this mutation only in the heterozygous state, in combination with other DTDST mutations, and never in the homozygous state. We now report the first instance of homozygosity for the c862t/R279W mutation in an adult whose phenotype was different from DTD and its variants. Findings in this subject expand the spectrum of DTDST associated disorders and support the notion that the c862t/R279W mutation may be a relatively “mild” mutation.

Case report

This 36 year old German engineer requested counselling for a presumed dominant form of multiple epiphyseal dysplasia. The family history was unremarkable and parental consanguinity was denied. Bilateral club foot had been surgically corrected in childhood and “hip dysplasia” had been treated with bandaging. Small femoral heads were observed in childhood. Lateral kneex rays at 8 years of age showed bilateral double layered patella. At puberty, brachydactyly became apparent.

On physical examination at the age of 36 years, he was 180 cm tall, the same as his father; his mother was 174 cm and a brother 183 cm tall. Neither his parents nor his brother had brachydactyly or foot deformities. The patient’s body habitus was unremarkable. He had discrepancy in leg length, which may have resulted from early ankle and foot surgery for club foot (see below). The facies was unremarkable, the palate was neither cleft nor high arched, and the external ears were well formed (no swelling reported). Body proportions were within the normal range. Left convex scoliosis was present in the lumbar region. The lower arms were slightly bowed and elbow flexion limited. The hands showed mild brachydactyly, although overall hand length was normal (fig 1B). The index fingers were unable to be bent completely at the metacarpophalangeal joint, but the mobility of the other finger joints was not limited. There was no hitch hiker thumb deformity. The feet and ankles showed some deformity resulting from surgical correction of congenital club foot, with more pronounced valgus position at the right ankle and hypotrophy of leg and foot muscles. The right big toe was deviated medially. The proband complained of pain in the hips, knees, and feet after physical exercise.

Figure 1

(A) The proband aged 36 years. Except for mild valgus deformity at the knees, the body habitus is unremarkable. (B) Left hand with mild brachydactyly and clinodactyly of the fifth finger. (C) Adduction of the right forefoot with wide spacing between the first and second toes. The left foot shows only mild shortening of the first toe. (D) Radiograph of the left hand showing moderate shortening of the metacarpals as well as of middle phalanges II and V.

Review of the x rays obtained during childhood showed inappropriately small epiphyses at several sites including the proximal femora (fig 2A), knees, humeri, distal radii, and ulnae. Lateral views of the knees at the age of 8 years, obtained because of complaints of restricted movement, showed an unusual finding consisting of two separate anterior and posterior ossification layers of the patella, the so-called double layered patella (fig 2C). In adulthood, there was marked flattening of proximal femoral epiphyses (fig 2B), mild shortening of the ulna, mild shortening of the metacarpals and medial phalanges II and V, and pronounced lumbar scoliosis apparently secondary to degenerative changes at L5/S1. On lateral projection, the vertebral bodies showed no platyspondyly nor significant dysplasia.

Figure 2

(A) Radiograph of the pelvis at the age of 3 years. Note small ossification centres of the proximal femoral epiphyses and the trochanter major. The femoral necks are short. (B) Follow up of the pelvis at the age of 36 years. The femoral necks are short and there is significant flattening of the proximal femoral epiphyses. The trochanters are of normal size at this stage. There also is localised degeneration of vertebral body S1 with lateral tilt of L5. (C) Lateral view of the knees at 8 years showing double layered patellae.

Laboratory investigations and results

Leucocyte DNA of the proband and of both parents was screened for mutations in the coding region of DTDST by genomic PCR and SSCP5-7 followed by direct PCR sequencing in both directions using dye terminators and an ABI 310 apparatus. The mutation status was confirmed by restriction enzyme analysis. The proband was homozygous, and the healthy parents heterozygous, for the c862t transition in DTDST predicting the substitution R279W in the fifth extracellular loop of the transporter protein (fig 3). No other mutation was observed in the coding region ofDTDST. Since functional proof of the causative role of the c862t/R279W mutation is lacking, the proband consented to undergo a skin biopsy for fibroblast culture. Sulphate incorporation in his fibroblast cultures was reduced to a level similar to other patients with diastrophic dysplasia8 (not shown), suggesting that the R279W mutation was indeed pathogenic, and confirming that his skeletal dysplasia was related to the DTDST bone dysplasia family. It must be noted that the sulphate incorporation assay is useful for diagnostic purposes but does not allow confident distinction between severe and milder variants.8

Figure 3

DNA sequence of genomic PCR products of a portion of the DTDST gene showing the c862t/R279W mutation in the homozygous state in the proband and in the heterozygous state in the mother (the father, not shown, was also heterozygous). The transition converts codon 279 from arginine to tryptophan.


Double layered patella is a rare and peculiar radiological finding which has been observed mostly in association with multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (MED).9-12 Patients with MED may also have forefoot adduction or club foot.9 13 14 Multiple epiphyseal dysplasia had therefore been diagnosed in this patient in his teens. Delayed development of the epiphyses without gross structural alterations, as seen in the radiograph of the pelvis taken at 3 years of age (fig 2A), is compatible with the diagnosis of MED. Normal stature is also a feature of milder forms of MED.

The clinical and radiological findings were re-evaluated when the proband requested genetic counselling for MED, which, in the known variants caused by mutations in the COMPgene (EDM1, MIM 132400) or the COL9A2 gene (EDM2, MIM 600204), is inherited as an autosomal dominant trait. The aim was to focus on a potential candidate locus for prenatal diagnosis. However, since club feet are not usually seen in MED caused byCOMP or COL9A2mutations, but are a feature of diastrophic dysplasia, evidence for a DTDST disorder was searched for. Homozygosity for a knownDTDST mutation and reduced sulphate incorporation in cultured fibroblasts confirm that the condition seen in the proband belongs to the DTDST bone dysplasia family (in spite of the absence of cleft palate, hitch hiker thumbs, changes in the external ears, and normal stature).

We have previously shown that the R279W mutation appears to result in DTDST mRNA of normal stability, as opposed to DTDST mRNA harbouring a premature stop codon.7 The findings in this proband also suggest that the c862t/R279W mutation, which affects an amino acid residue in an extracellular loop of the transporter protein, is relatively “mild” and explains why we had not observed homozygosity in the patient population we had studied before, a population ascertained for the three known DTDST phenotypes, ACG1B, AO2, and DTD. It seems likely that this mutation allows for some residual activity of the transporter protein, with an additive effect in homozygotes accounting for the mild phenotype.

Although variability in diastrophic dysplasia has been recognised for a long time, none of the subjects with the “diastrophic variant” reported by Horton et al 15 and Lachman et al 16 reached a final stature of 150 cm or more, and a DTDST related condition with tall-normal stature has not been predicted. Since c862t/R279W appears to be the most frequent DTDST mutation in Europe (except for Finland), homozygotes may not be particularly rare. The diagnostic value of the double layered patella and, perhaps more importantly, of club foot remains to be established. Identification of the molecular defect was good news for our proband, as the estimation of the risk of having affected offspring could be reduced from the 50% of a presumedly dominant condition to the much lower risk of a recessive condition.

The McKusick catalogue contains an entry on autosomal recessive multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (*226900) based on the description of three affected sibs by Juberg and Holt.13Spranger17 has suggested that these cases were instances of “diastrophic variants”. The sibs described by Juberg and Holt13 had moderately reduced stature (adult stature around 150 cm), but the clinical and radiographic findings were similar to those seen in our proband (including a double layered patella), supporting Spranger’s suggestion. The three sibs with “double patellae and multiple epiphysial dysplasia” reported by Hodkinson9 also had forefoot adduction; their adult stature was around 150 cm. In spite of the tall stature in the subject reported here contrasting with these observations, it does not appear appropriate to create yet another different entity, since we are dealing with a continuous spectrum of related conditions. We therefore suggest that MIM entry 226900 may be definitively assigned to “autosomal recessive multiple epiphyseal dysplasia” caused byDTDST mutations. Within this recessive form of MED associated with DTDST mutations, the relative frequency of normal versus moderately reduced stature and the diagnostic value of double layered patella remains to be established.


We are grateful to Professor Andres Giedion for comments on the radiographical findings and on the manuscript. This work was supported by the Swiss National Foundation (32-45401.95).


View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.